Listen, don't all of you jump down my throat all at once ...but, I'm actually in favor of outlawing any form of tackle that has a history of injuring NFL players. If outlawing the horse collar tackle will reduce the possibilty of injury, then I'm all for it!
Flame throwers would be quick to jump at an opportunity to suggest that I'm only saying that because of the 2004 T.O. injury. And it's true, while there have been several incidents of the Horsecollar tackle other than from Roy Williams, the T.O. injury probably is the "poster child" case; with Roy Williams' being tagged with the "signature tackle."
But if the poster child case is inflicted on a significant Cowboy's playmaker (I truly hope it doesn't), many of you (perhaps not everyone) would change their tune.
One more thought ...instead of focusing your energies on re-instating the now notorious outlawed horsecollar tackle, why not advocate the design on the uniform collar that retards this type of tackle. For example, let's take the face mask penalty. I'd like to see a newly designed face mask that prevents anyone from gripping it. Something that serves the same purpose, yet unlike the "bars" that go across the width of the helmet. Hence, the face-mask penalty would be a non-factor.
Just something to think about, and as usual ...a different perspective.
...you're already in a world of ...
Full, Metal, Jacket) ...see it soon!
RB Brian Westbrook