I think it depends. Let's go crazy and say the team makes it to the NFC Championship. Would you want to bring almost everyone back for another run? I think if we end up tapering off and going the dreaded 8-8 again we will be a lot less likely to bring everyone back.
Second, I don't think we are flush with cap space next year. According to overthecap.com, we have 136m committed to the cap with only 41 players signed and our dead money. In those numbers are the deals signed by Carr, Melton, Free, Smith and Romo. Obviously we can make room with those, some options affect future cap.
Best thing would be if Carr. Melton, Free and Romo agreed to restructure, cutting their scheduled base salaries. That way we can keep the players and gain room. None of them are worth what their salary is next year.
From free agency, we have:
RFA
Dunbar
Beasley
Leary
Little
J. Crawford
D. Weems
I would say Beasley, Leary are for sure to be tendered. Dunbar possibly and maybe Weems.
UFA
Parnell
Murray
Moore
McClain
Jones
Hayden
Harris
Durant
Clutts
Carter
Bryant
Brent
Selvie
Spencer
Spillman
What really sucks is we have drafted fairly well the last few years and now we either have to pay them or start over. In a perfect world, we would definitely be signing Murray, Moore, McClain, Jones, Harris, Carter and Bryant. If they have good seasons, would want to consider Selvie, Spencer and Durant.
Offseason is going to be one filled with interesting moves. As such, I am pretty much just going to sit back, watch the season play out and then worry about next year's team when this year's games are done.