Gil Brandt: You can have one QB (currently college or NFL), who you taking?

[RonnieT24]

What concerns me with Murray is they're with where he's attempting less than 20 passes a game.

The 49ers got to the Super Bowl with their guy doing that throughout their playoff run last year.. and the Titans won like two playoff games last year doing it..

 

[CATCH17]

Lawrence

 

[KingintheNorth]

If it's for 1 game or the next 3 years, it's Mahomes

If its for the next decade to 15 years, give me D.J. Uiagalelei. 6'4" 249 and only 19.

I won.

 

[CATCH17]

What concerns me with Murray is they're with where he's attempting less than 20 passes a game.

Kyler is good because of his acceleration. He’s a decent passer too don’t get me wrong but what makes him good is his wheels.. I always worry about guys like that because once the wheels are gone they lose what makes them special.

 

[fivetwos]

Because there would be no debate lol. 100 out of 100 people take Mahomes lol

Yep.

And while the answers here may depend on if you're talking about one season or long term....

Same guy in whichever case. Mahomes.

Is it actually close? Shouldnt really be.

 

[CATCH17]

If it's for 1 game or the next 3 years, it's Mahomes

If its for the next decade to 15 years, give me D.J. Uiagalelei. 6'4" 249 and only 19.

I won.

Mahomes isn’t an option.

He’s already reached all time talents.

Like Mahomes or John Elway. Aaron Rodgers.. Those types.

 

[cowboyec]

D4K

 

[Teague31]

Burrow. That kid is the real deal.

 

[jrumann59]

harsh!

The youngest commentator that was a QB is Romo, then Aikman, Simms and Boomer

 

[Redsfan_83]

Herbert all day from what he has shown so far...

 

[dfense]

The question was, 1 QB.

He lists like 12. "You no listen?"

 

[erod]

Joe Burrow.

Easy.

 

[bigE79]

I'm STICKING with Dak..........

Josh Allen..he just impresses me anytime I see him play and people say he has the strongest arm in the league.

 

[dsturgeon]

Russel wilson and seahawk style of offense, with our skill posistion players

 

[zrinkill]

Mahomes ..... Easy

 

[Jake]

Some people should actually read the OP.

On that list? Herbert. He's doing things no rookie QB has ever done.

Chargers sweat, struggle to beat Jets as Justin Herbert’s season hits historic level

 

[tyke1doe]

Herbert. He is single-handedly ... keeping in me in contention for my fantasy football playoffs.

Then Lawrence

Then Watson

Then Tua

 

[JBS]

If it's for 1 game or the next 3 years, it's Mahomes

If its for the next decade to 15 years, give me D.J. Uiagalelei. 6'4" 249 and only 19.

I won.

Mahomes is better than Ukelele for the next 15 years too

 

[waving monkey]

You are taking Tua over Herbert? How

I taking Herbert over Tua and I love Tua.
Herbert has just about everything,height,athlete and the best passer.
Tua has everything till he gets hit wrong
Im a big big Herbert fan.

 

[Future]

Some of those guys are first year QBs or unknowns. Murray looks to be improving at a high rate, considering his rookie year looked like a complete bust I'd take him and his little legs.

Kyler? He's looked pretty abysmal as a passer lately.

Dak, Watson, Herbert and Lawrence are really the only ones in contention.