Go vote for cowboys best QB franchise!

[Outlaw Heroes]

Packers now in 2nd place, 49ers to 3rd.

I don't agree with that.

Nope. But, truth be told, it's hard for me to justify the Cowboys placing ahead of the 49ers. Montana would rank ahead of Roger on most people's lists. Young and Aikman would rank around even in most people's eyes (though I'd take Aikman any day of the week). Y.A. Tittle has to rank ahead of our next best guy (whether that's Meredith, White or Romo, I don't know at this point). And Brodie might even be even with our next best guy, whoever that is.

We've had a great history of QBs. Has it been better than the '9ers? Much as I hate to admit it, I don't think so.

 

[hutch1254]

Here are two things with this poll that got my brain going.

• Eagles are on there with all their garbage with no super bowls to back it up.
• Steelers are NOT on the list and have 6 super bowls.

And I love how we have over 1000 votes.

 

[DallasEast]

Here are two things with this poll that got my brain going.

• Eagles are on there with all their garbage with no super bowls to back it up.
• Steelers are NOT on the list and have 6 super bowls.

And I love how we have over 1000 votes.

It's an eastern Pennsylvania conspiracy! :

 

[Cowboy Brian]

The fact that Vick made the cut for the Eagles is pathetic, and the fact that the Giants are on it imo mainly because of the accolades from a QB that was on the team for 4 years is sad.

The only question is Cowboys v. 49ers, and Romo, White and Meredith > Garcia & Brodie... So it is the Cowboys, thats not even a biased vote at all..

Although in a couple years the Packers may make a run at it.

 

[LeonDixson]

Packers now in 2nd place, 49ers to 3rd.

I don't agree with that.

Packers fans are rabid internet clickers. Remember that Campbells soup charity thing they used to sponsor? The pack fans won it every year IIRC, and I know they don't have as many fans as Cowboys and some other teams.

 

[Red Dragon]

Wow, we're crushing in the vote lead now!

 

[Red Dragon]

As much as I hate the Steelers (and I hate them viciously,) how do they not get mention, with Bradshaw (4 rings) and Rollthisbooger (2 rings?)

 

[jobberone]

As much as I hate the Steelers (and I hate them viciously,) how do they not get mention, with Bradshaw (4 rings) and Rollthisbooger (2 rings?)

I don't think Bradshaw was that great of a QB. Those were great Steelers teams. Roth**** is a pretty good QB and very clutch. He's still not the talent of an Aikman or Staubach. Neither one of them are.

 

[Zaxor]

Nope. But, truth be told, it's hard for me to justify the Cowboys placing ahead of the 49ers. Montana would rank ahead of Roger on most people's lists. Young and Aikman would rank around even in most people's eyes (though I'd take Aikman any day of the week). Y.A. Tittle has to rank ahead of our next best guy (whether that's Meredith, White or Romo, I don't know at this point). And Brodie might even be even with our next best guy, whoever that is.

We've had a great history of QBs. Has it been better than the '9ers? Much as I hate to admit it, I don't think so.

Wow I disagreed on many levels... I started to list which team had most playoff appearances, most winning seasons, most SB appearances...I wanted to point to the fact that most people who do not know what they are talking about think Rice was the best player of all time and he was there for Montana and Young or what HOF WR was Roger throwing to most of his career as Bullet was just about used up the time they won the first SB or what HOF TE Roger had (answer to both was none though Ditka and Jackie Smith had short stints) and while Dallas had HOF RB's that opens a can of worms called team concepts which makes judging any individual playing football hard...but especially hard for QB. So all I can say is I would take the Cowboys QB and I believe in my heart I could win against any other team(s) you choose...

 

[cowboyeric8]

This needs to be an episode of NFLN's Top 10

 

[LeonDixson]

Wow I disagreed on many levels... I started to list which team had most playoff appearances, most winning seasons, most SB appearances...I wanted to point to the fact that most people who do not know what they are talking about think Rice was the best player of all time and he was there for Montana and Young or what HOF WR was Roger throwing to most of his career as Bullet was just about used up the time they won the first SB or what HOF TE Roger had (answer to both was none though Ditka and Jackie Smith had short stints) and while Dallas had HOF RB's that opens a can of worms called team concepts which makes judging any individual playing football hard...but especially hard for QB. So all I can say is I would take the Cowboys QB and I believe in my heart I could win against any other team(s) you choose...

And while he was there, Jackie Smith dropped a sure TD pass in the SB that might have helped the Cowboys win.

 

[BubbleScreen]

I like how Vick is credited to the Eagles but Dallas gets no credit for Randall Cunningham. LOL.

Seriously, Jaws and McNabb are both Danny White level QBs. Very good, but not (in a serious discussion) all time greats. The Browns are more impressive than the Eagles, and that's if you only count Otto Graham and Tim Couch.

 

[Zaxor]

And while he was there, Jackie Smith dropped a sure TD pass in the SB that might have helped the Cowboys win.

augh give the knife another twist there Leon...that still kills me

 

[PullMyFinger]

Surprised they dont have the Stealers on the list. 5 more votes for the boys