Goff vs Prescott

[percyhoward]

Goff was, literally, the worst starting QB in the NFL from the end of November on. He’s been awful since the Lions/Bears games.

Maybe not the worst, but bottom 10.

2nd half of season + playoffs
1 Wilson 112.4
2 Mahomes 109.5
3 Mayfield 106.2
4 Brees 105.5
5 Watson 101.7
6 Prescott 101.2
7 Ryan 101.1

23 Goff 86.6

 

[Roadtrip635]

 

[TWOK11]

Maybe not the worst, but bottom 10.

2nd half of season + playoffs
1 Wilson 112.4
2 Mahomes 109.5
3 Mayfield 106.2
4 Brees 105.5
5 Watson 101.7
6 Prescott 101.2
7 Ryan 101.1

23 Goff 86.6

I said since the end of November, which is the last 5 regular season games and 3 playoff games. His QB rating and QBR in that time would have been good for 2nd to last and dead last respectively for the season.

 

[CATCH17]

I’d take Dak.


Goff is completely dependent on his coaching.

 

[Romo_To_Dez]

I will say that Goff proves how much coaching matters. When McVay couldn't find an answer to what Belechick was doing, Goff looked closer to his days with Fisher tonight. I'll just say that the gap isn't as big as some make it seem. While Dak does need better coaching, a strong supporting cast, and a solid running game to reach his full potential. Goff is also the type of QB who leans more towards needing coaching and a strong supporting cast, in order to consistently win.

He is far away from being more of the Brady type of QB, who can have any player plugged in on offense and still have his team be a playoff team. Even though coaching plays a huge part in the Patriots having 6 Superbowls. I believe that Goff is closer to a game manager than he is to what people believe it takes to be a true elite NFL QB.

 

[jwitten82]

No, he didn’t. Their running game and a officiating travesty got them to the SB.

Dak Prescott has never had an 8 and stretch as bad as Goff’s last 8.

Lol you forgot the second half of last season where Dak had 6 td and 9 ints

 

[Batman1980]

Both look to be middle of the road qbs.

One cost the 1st pick overall in the draft. One was the 8th QB off the board in the same draft. One was trending up at the end of the season. One has been in a slump for about 3 months. I'll let you guess which is which.

 

[percyhoward]

I said since the end of November.

I know you did. He's 26th since then, or "bottom 7."

 

[Romo_To_Dez]

So, basically what everyone holds against Dak, counts against Goff. The "He can't win or be productive on offense without a run game." criticism.

 

[NorthwestDallas40]

Let’s see how Dak does with a new OC with some creativity, a healthy OL, and a full offseason with Coop and Gallup, and maybe a new TE. Just don’t understand the Dak hate when the guy lost his TE, #1 WR, and C before week 1 and still led his team to a division title and playoff win.

 

[Little Jr]

But Dak doesnt have the throwing skills of Goff. Overall Goff had a better season...why do Dak fans have to try and tear down every qb? Im surprised nobody has made a dak vs brady thread

That's a good question and I totally agree. Dak fans shouldn't tear down other qbs to try to prove daks worth.

But here's another question , which is worst, cowboy fans who tears down another QB, or a cowboy fans who tears down their own QB and most of the time, prop up other QBs?

The really sad thing is, I'm called a dak fan. I'm actually called a fan of a player who is on my team I root for.

 

[blumayne38]

So only passing TDs count not rushing?

Is he a RB? We pay him to throw the ball not run it

 

[NumOneQB]

Let’s see how Dak does with a new OC with some creativity, a healthy OL, and a full offseason with Coop and Gallup, and maybe a new TE. Just don’t understand the Dak hate when the guy lost his TE, #1 WR, and C before week 1 and still led his team to a division title and playoff win.

And we all see what happened when a legitimate #1 WR arrived for the offense. That’s where my opinion on Dak slowly started to change, when Coop showed up.
However, the biggest hurdle is the front office. Going into the season with no #1 wr and a questionable change to the offensive blocking scheme about tanked the season wbfore it even started. We’re beating a dead horse but we all know the reality of the situation in Dallas...

 

[Roadtrip635]

Patriots players said Goff will *bleep* his pants......

 

[Batman1980]

And we all see what happened when a legitimate #1 WR arrived for the offense. That’s where my opinion on Dak slowly started to change, when Coop showed up.

Let's see how you deal with it with Hurns, Thompson, Williams, Gallup and Beasley as your top receivers and in constant rotation.

 

[America's Cowboy]

32 pass tds this season, meanwhile dak cant crack 25 in an offensive league

Goff has been surrounded with a very good and healthy Oline, very good RBs and lots of weapons at WR and TE. Plus, a genius Head Coach/O-Coordinator and a very good D.

What has Dak had???

 

[NumOneQB]

Let's see how you deal with it with Hurns, Thompson, Williams, Gallup and Beasley as your top receivers and in constant rotation.

?

 

[CalPolyTechnique]

But Dak doesnt have the throwing skills of Goff. Overall Goff had a better season...why do Dak fans have to try and tear down every qb? Im surprised nobody has made a dak vs brady thread

Because they’re barely functioning human beings and even lesser football fans.

 

[CalPolyTechnique]

Whats his career comp% vs Daks?

What’s their career YPC?

 

[Super_Kazuya]

LOL @ Dak slobberers thinking Dak is anywhere close to being as good as Goff. Dak will finally get his crack to see how things go against Belichick next season. I’m sure that is going to go just great for him.