Twitter: Grade your QB

[Hadenough]

The Cowboys against bad teams are a well oiled machine. They can beat you with the pass or the run. Against playoff teams they are one dimensional. If they aren't running the ball well they cant beat you with the pass.
Dak was awful tight against that Colts defense the other night. I would say he gets a C grade.

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

Go to sleep and wake up in the Playoffs....the Process is called the season.

Josh Allen is comparative analysis...what should we compare him to air.....

The Gassed Up fans are you those who think Josh Allen is a cut above....

IF Dak had Buffaloes past defenses in the Playoffs does he win more than One?

If dak gets down last year and spikes the ball do they win? That was entirely in his control.

his failure to lineup jalen Tolbert may very well cost them the super bowl, again that’s his job as leader.

I don’t really care what josh Allen does, I think he’s more talented than dak. If dak wants to be on commercials on my tv he better be better than throwing constant waddling ducks and blaming his tremendous wr’s.
We’re about to have two 1,000 yard rushers. I think only 8 teams have had this ? His defense leads the league in everything. His offensive line is so good we are gonna rotate them to get them on the field. If he’s gonna have all that is to too much to ask that he stops throwing first half interceptions and Miss wide open throws? He’s gonna get ceedee some broken ribs with these ducks.

 

[Redline360]

I'll give him a solid B.

When asked simply to drive the bus straight and not be the focal point he does great. Last two games worried me some though. Could have been a turnover machine if not for incredibly lucky breaks or easy drops.

The only thing I would like to see change is the slow starts.

 

[StarOfGlory]

Offense has been on fire with Dak. B+, could be an A once the turnovers stop.

 

[JoeKing]

I'm not grading my QB while he is studying for his big exam (playoffs). I'll grade my QB in the offseason.

 

[Chuck 54]

I dont know what their letter grades are but Chris Canty, Bart Scott and Orlovsky aren't overly impressed with him off the top of my head.

He has warts, as most QBs, even those winning SBs do. They point out his warts, as they should. But none of them have ever referred to him as a below average QB. That’s why I stand by my statement. I give Dak a B+, but I’m not going to argue with someone who thinks he’s a C+. That still makes him above average. I never gave Romo above a B because he seemed to melt down in the big games. If Dak never reaches the NFC title game, I’ll drop his score too, but right now I think he’s more dedicated and mentally tough than Romo.

 

[Qcard]

If dak gets down last year and spikes the ball do they win? That was entirely in his control.

his failure to lineup jalen Tolbert may very well cost them the super bowl, again that’s his job as leader.

I don’t really care what josh Allen does, I think he’s more talented than dak. If dak wants to be on commercials on my tv he better be better than throwing constant waddling ducks and blaming his tremendous wr’s.
We’re about to have two 1,000 yard rushers. I think only 8 teams have had this ? His defense leads the league in everything. His offensive line is so good we are gonna rotate them to get them on the field. If he’s gonna have all that is to too much to ask that he stops throwing first half interceptions and Miss wide open throws? He’s gonna get ceedee some broken ribs with these ducks.

Diatribe is wack....ALL QBs make those mistakes.

See you in the Playoffs ..Seasonal Whining is unbecoming of a mature fan

 

[FVSTONE]

I'm going with B-.........he is way better than average but needs a little more consistency to say "mostly great" IMO.

(2) Sunday Night Football on NBC on Twitter: "Grade your quarterback this season. #NFL https://t.co/dbvrK35H5F" / Twitter

I'm going with a solid D, reason being is Prescot once again displayed his inabilities to get this offense on track AGAIN! These slow starts are giving our opponents life in games. The Dolts looked like a playoff contender for 3 quarters and it if wasn't for Mattie Ice's poor decisions and some OUTSTANDING play by our defense the outcome of this game could have been a lot different.

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

Diatribe is wack....ALL QBs make those mistakes.

See you in the Playoffs ..Seasonal Whining is unbecoming of a mature fan

You’re welcome for the High level Analysis mid week. Enjoy your footy pajamas but the question is what grade do you give the player. He isn’t breaking all these tackles in the open field. The wide receiver everyone tried to blame is doing the heavy lifting.

 

[lopey]

B- Needs to be more aware of protecting the ball

 

[aikemirv]

Colts game he was a C. The slow starts are going to kill us faster than the run defense

A in red zone - D everywhere else so I will slide that up to a B-

 

[DoctorChicken]

C- the other night. B- overall.

 

[lukin2006]

I’ll give him a B…

 

[bewp7]

d

he is a franchise qb held to back up qb standard

just hand the ball off and dont turn it over and he cant even do that with his stupid int every game

 

[starfan1]

I'm going with a solid D, reason being is Prescot once again displayed his inabilities to get this offense on track AGAIN! These slow starts are giving our opponents life in games. The Dolts looked like a playoff contender for 3 quarters and it if wasn't for Mattie Ice's poor decisions and some OUTSTANDING play by our defense the outcome of this game could have been a lot different.

How did Mahomes look against the Dolts? Enquiring minds want to know

 

[UncleRico]

I'm going with B-.........he is way better than average but needs a little more consistency to say "mostly great" IMO.

(2) Sunday Night Football on NBC on Twitter: "Grade your quarterback this season. #NFL https://t.co/dbvrK35H5F" / Twitter

With Dak it’s hard. One week you get A+ performance then you get a C performance. He’s been elite sometimes and head scratching others. We just need consistency. Dak has the ability to win a super bowl though. So I’ll go B+.

 

[Swagger]

C+ for me.

He's playing on a loaded roster compared with the vast majority of other quarterbacks in the league yet he still manages to stink up the joint some weeks. Benefiting from a strong running game and a dominant defense giving him more drives and excellent starting field position. We would have beaten the Packers with a number of other quarterbacks in the league and those close games are when he needs to show up and be the difference between winning and losing not make excuses. So he still goes as the players around him go.

If C is regarded as average then C+ seems about right.

 

[SiCk_DiAbLo]

I'm looking for more deep passes, less int's. C+

 

[john van brocklin]

I'm going with B-.........he is way better than average but needs a little more consistency to say "mostly great" IMO.

(2) Sunday Night Football on NBC on Twitter: "Grade your quarterback this season. [url=https://newsreadery.com/?q=NFL]#NFL https://t.co/dbvrK35H5F" / Twitter[/URL]

Solid "B".
Better than average but too inconsistent to be rated higher.

 

[cnuball21]

C+ for me.

He's playing on a loaded roster compared with the vast majority of other quarterbacks in the league yet he still manages to stink up the joint some weeks. Benefiting from a strong running game and a dominant defense giving him more drives and excellent starting field position. We would have beaten the Packers with a number of other quarterbacks in the league and those close games are when he needs to show up and be the difference between winning and losing not make excuses. So he still goes as the players around him go.

If C is regarded as average then C+ seems about right.

The “loaded roster” thing always strikes me as odd. Obviously the defense is great but do you honestly believe Dak has a great group of WRs?

Looking at the NFC playoffs teams, outside of the Giants, the Cowboys have the worst WR corp in the league and it’s not even debatable IMO. Like not even close.

Eagles (AJ and Devonta)
49ers (Deebo, Aiyuk and Kittle)
Hawks (DK and Lockett)
Vikings (JJ and Thielen)
Bucs (Evans and Godwin)