Greatest RB Game

[ajk23az]

This list is evidence of the homers we are as cowboys fans. Put this on a national level, and I don't think there is a single national reporter who would have chosen Emmitt over Barry any season they were both in their prime. What Barry Sanders did without a quality offensive line and without another star position player to keep defenses honest is beyond astounding. I love Emmitt, but seriously- 45 to 15?

Did Barry ever win a Super Bowl?
Is Barry the all time leading rusher?
Does Barry have the most rushing TDs in NFL History?

I think not..

Its not Emmitts fault Barry retired early...

 

[The Rawhide Kid]

Did Barry ever win a Super Bowl?
Is Barry the all time leading rusher?
Does Barry have the most rushing TDs in NFL History?

I think not..

Its not Emmitts fault Barry retired early...

But it is Emmitt's fault that he had such a great offensive line; it was so good we should probably put an asterisk by all his records just to be fair.

 

[ajk23az]

But it is Emmitt's fault that he had such a great offensive line; it was so good we should probably put an asterisk by all his records just to be fair.

:laugh2: Exactly.

 

[DallasFanSince86]

Jim Brown 47
Emmitt Smith 44
Walter Payton 41+
Earl Campbell 28
Eric Dickerson 19
Tony Dorsett 15
OJ Simpson 11-
Barry Sanders 16
Gale Sayers 7

 

[Hostile]

Jim Brown 47
Emmitt Smith 44
Walter Payton 42+
Earl Campbell 28
Eric Dickerson 19
Tony Dorsett 15
OJ Simpson 11
Barry Sanders 15-
Gale Sayers 7

 

[Big Country]

Jim Brown 47
Emmitt Smith 44
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 28
Eric Dickerson 20+
Tony Dorsett 15
OJ Simpson 11
Barry Sanders 15
Gale Sayers 6-

 

[dalboy]

Jim Brown 47
Emmitt Smith 45+
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 28
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
OJ Simpson 11
Barry Sanders 14-
Gale Sayers 6

 

[Chuck 54]

Jim Brown 47
Emmitt Smith 45
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 27-
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
OJ Simpson 12+
Barry Sanders 14
Gale Sayers 6

 

[The Grim Reaper]

Jim Brown 48+
Emmitt Smith 45
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 27
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
OJ Simpson 11-
Barry Sanders 14
Gale Sayers 6

 

[Dhragon]

Jim Brown 48
Emmitt Smith 45
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 27
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
OJ Simpson 11
Barry Sanders 15+
Gale Sayers 5-

 

[Mavs Man]

Jim Brown 48
Emmitt Smith 46+
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 27
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
Barry Sanders 14-
OJ Simpson 11
Gale Sayers 5

 

[Chuck 54]

Jim Brown 48
Emmitt Smith 46
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 26-
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
Barry Sanders 14
OJ Simpson 12+
Gale Sayers 5

 

[Chuck 54]

Jim Brown 48
Emmitt Smith 46
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 25-
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
Barry Sanders 14
OJ Simpson 13+
Gale Sayers 5

 

[Chuck 54]

Jim Brown 48
Emmitt Smith 46
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 24-
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
Barry Sanders 14
OJ Simpson 14+
Gale Sayers 5

 

[Chuck 54]

Jim Brown 48
Emmitt Smith 46
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 23-
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
Barry Sanders 14
OJ Simpson 15+
Gale Sayers 5

 

[Chuck 54]

Jim Brown 48
Emmitt Smith 46
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 22-
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
Barry Sanders 14
OJ Simpson 16+
Gale Sayers 5

 

[Chuck 54]

Jim Brown 48
Emmitt Smith 46
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 21-
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
Barry Sanders 14
OJ Simpson 17+
Gale Sayers 5

So I'm bored....I'll be out of town this weekend...might as well get all my repetitious votes in now.

 

[jackrussell]

Jim Brown 48
Emmitt Smith 46
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 21-
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
Barry Sanders 14
OJ Simpson 17+
Gale Sayers 5

So I'm bored....I'll be out of town this weekend...might as well get all my repetitious votes in now.

One vote per day.

Corrected list.

Jim Brown 48
Emmitt Smith 46
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 27
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
Barry Sanders 14
OJ Simpson 11
Gale Sayers 5

 

[Skinsmaniac]

Jim Brown 48
Emmitt Smith 46
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 21-
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
Barry Sanders 14
OJ Simpson 17+
Gale Sayers 5

So I'm bored....I'll be out of town this weekend...might as well get all my repetitious votes in now.

Uh, can we get a ruling on voting seven times in a row? Otherwise, I could vote for the next 46 days and eliminate Emmitt Smith right now. I think we should stick to one day, one vote.

Edit: beat me to it.

 

[kojak]

Jim Brown 48
Emmitt Smith 47 +
Walter Payton 42
Earl Campbell 27
Eric Dickerson 20
Tony Dorsett 15
Barry Sanders 14
OJ Simpson 10 -
Gale Sayers 5