Luckily this was not as bad as Katrina.
No, it absolutely was not as bad. At least for me.
I live outside of New Orleans ( basically north and east of N.O.) and rode out both Katrina 15 years ago and Ida last night. Speaking for my own personal experience, there was no comparison between the two. Last night we just had a lot of wind and rain. There are very few trees down around here… and some limbs, etc….But it is nothing like what Katrina did here. Nothing. Katrina put 7 trees on my house, made
all roads impassable for days afterwards, and killed a couple of people in my neighborhood. With Ida, we didn’t even lose power (although some people in this area did).
However, we are on the East side of New Orleans And Katrina went East of N.O. Ida went West of N.O. and the core simply didn’t come as close to me as Katrina’s, so the impact should have been lessened here.
My wife’s sister lives Northwest of New Orleans (Hammond) and she said that last night she had never been so scared in her life. She said that it was much worse than what she went through with Katrina, so it is just a matter of where you were, I suppose.
Katrina, for all that New Orleans made the news after her, really didn’t get the worst of Katrina. It was Mississippi that bore the brunt of the attack. Louisiana was primarily a flood event, with all the levees breaking. They really didn’t get that much wind. Mississippi got the front-right quadrant of Katrina. The wind and especially the storm surge was much worse for MS. The storm surge was the worst part for the MS coast. It was truly catastrophic.
With Ida though, south LA got the front-right quadrant and my sister-in-law was able to experience wind like we did for Katrina.
The thing that Katrina had that Ida did not was size. Katrina was such a massive, massive storm that it brought unprecedented storm surge with it. The hurricane basically lifts up the water and brings it onshore with it with its low pressure. It isn’t just a “wind blowing the water onshore” thing. The huge size Katrina had brought so much water with it that some parts of the coast like Long Beach and Pass Christian got around 25 feet of storm surge. That is incredible.
Hurricane Camille hit in exactly the same spot as Katrina, and as bad as the winds were in that (200 mph gusts), it didn’t bring nearly as much water with it.
Anyway. I’m rambling… but Ida wasn’t Katrina despite being a cat-4.