You part of the E-Lie Love Club?
I no longer look at players for other teams and think because they are a part of a franchise other than Dallas, they stink. Because too many times they end up on the Dallas roster. T.O., Deion, Pacman.
I think Eli is an accurate passer who has an uncanny ability to throw the ball where it needs to be thrown. I watched both Super Bowls he played in, just like all the other Super Bowls and saw nothing that would suggest to me he is any more or less lucky than any other quarterback.
I think he thinks quickly, which is an attribute of an NFL starter for as long as he has been around.
I believe he is on the same tier with Romo, which is not the top tier.
I also believe if Romo had the Giants defense he would have a ring now. And perhaps should have.
But as long as Eli has two SB wins, he still is above Romo regardless of excuse making by some. Because it isn't always the defense that losses for this team.
Does that answer your question?