Mash said:
I agree that Ellis will improve because of being more comfortable....but for a LB......Ellis is slow......a few times the Washington RB just ran around him in open space.....Ellis is not quick enough to play the flat....more teams will see this and expose it......
Ellis strength is stopping the run and rushing the passer when he is put as a DL.
BTW.....I also think Carpenter is too slow for OLB and I believe that is one of the reason he was moved inside.
I agree with your comments about Ellis. I had a poster fight me tooth and nail last week for making similar comments about Ellis. The guy even ranted about how playing OLB would be almost the same for Ellis as playing DE. Obviously when rushing the passer that is true, but when falling back in coverage that is blatently not true. Coverage is the area where Ellis has a long way to go and some physical limitations.
As for Carpenter, I disagree about his speed. He is supposed to be able to run a 4.6 40 - plenty of speed to play OLB.
I'm really not sure what prompted the move to ILB. He did play some ILB in college, but I suspect the move now has more to do with the Cowboys personnel than anything. Perhaps Ayodele is the biggest LB question mark in Parcells mind - after all he also is making a transition from OLB. Maybe Parcells just sees something in Carpenter that he thinks translates better to ILB than OLB or he just doesn't like our depth on the inside as much as on the outside. It's really hard to say.
I did notice Carpenter playing a lot in passing situattions last night. Maybe Parcells likes to have Carpenter's speed in the game in passing situations but doesn't want to have to take out Ware or Ellis - his 2 primary pass rushers - to get Carpenter in the game. I certainly would expect that Carpenter has more range in passing situations than Ayodele.