Good play calling is about setting up options for future plays. If you throw it deep every time you get 2nd and 2, there is no disguise as to what you are going to do. And if you miss it, now you have a tricky 3rd and 2 which can stall out your drive. And in the end, if you can get more first downs than your opponent, you're typically going to win the game. That's really how the West Coast Offense evolved. It was Bill Walsh seeing that tallying more first downs than the opponent will likely win you the game.
My issue with the playcalling is that we kept using shotgun and even worse, empty backfield...particularly on 1st and 2nd down. The entire defense knows you're not going to run the ball. And now they can come up with all of these different blitzes. It wasn't like the offense was shredding the Eagles using shotgun and empty backfield sets. In fact, Romo kept getting hit.
And we still snap the ball at the last .00001 seconds when we are on the road. It may work early on, but in the end it will hurt the team. We saw this today as Romo started to get into the habit of doing that and in the end he threw a pick. When we got the ball back, we started snapping the ball earlier and drove right down and scored a TD.
To me, it's a triad of Garrett-Callahan-Romo that worries me. Callahan calls to many pass plays, shot guns and empty backfields. Romo likes to audible out of running plays the hint of a blitz and audibles too much. And Garrett doesn't keep them in check.
YR