If Cleveland called and offered Mayfield for Dak straight up

giphy.gif
 
big dog cowboy said:
Baker Mayfield is the most overrated player in the league.
Click to expand...

Biggest problem with Mayfield is Cleveland has good skill players but no OL. Their blocking looks like trying to hold back water with a fish net. Next biggest problem is he was overhyped before he earned it, much like RG3.

To the original question, no. Mayfield's teammates would make that trade in a heartbeat and help him pack. I don't think he's well liked in the Browns locker room at all.
 
No. Pretty much the same type of QB but Prescott is taller and less likely to get injured given his bigger body.
 
What compensation is Cleveland sending along? Couple first round picks? Haha
 
Verdict said:
If Cleveland called and offered Mayfield for Dak straight up how many of you would be for that?
Click to expand...
Nope! I want a 6-5 QB that is the whole package. Can make throws with touch, velocity and accuracy. Can make all the throws from the route tree.
 
No to Mayfield for Dak. I'd be more inclined to resign Dak or go through the draft. Cleveland's not trading Mayfield anyway, they've invested so much and he's the face of the franchise.

How about this though.... OBJ for a first, a third and Connor Williams assuming Cooper's camp plays hard ball and can't come to an agreement on an extension.
 
Mayfield has weapons and is struggling with them. So, where's the guarantee that he would do better than what Dak is doing for the Cowboys right now?
 
Hailmary said:
No to Mayfield for Dak. I'd be more inclined to resign Dak or go through the draft. Cleveland's not trading Mayfield anyway, they've invested so much and he's the face of the franchise.

How about this though.... OBJ for a first, a third and Connor Williams assuming Cooper's camp plays hard ball and can't come to an agreement on an extension.
Click to expand...
Absolutely not! OBJ is not that good, he has lived off his couple of circus catches he had against the Cowboys.
 
PJTHEDOORS said:
Why? What's Mayfield gonna do that Dak is cuurently doing (70.6% completions)?
Click to expand...

If Mayfield thinks that he is facing too much heat and unfair questions by the media and reporters while being a QB of the Browns, imagine what he would face while being the QB for the Cowboys and the amount of criticism and scrutiny that comes with being a QB on the Cowboys while they have lost a game or go on a losing streak.

Being a QB is more than about talent, it's about whether or not a QB can compose himself when facing criticism, especially playing for a team like the Cowboys.
 
Not a chance without a couple of high draft picks included with Mayfield..........Mayfield is light years behind Dak.
 
Hailmary said:
No to Mayfield for Dak. I'd be more inclined to resign Dak or go through the draft. Cleveland's not trading Mayfield anyway, they've invested so much and he's the face of the franchise.

How about this though.... OBJ for a first, a third and Connor Williams assuming Cooper's camp plays hard ball and can't come to an agreement on an extension.
Click to expand...

"I am Mr. Rourke, your host, and welcome to Fantasy Island."
 
When I first watched Mayfield's "Home" series of commercials, I probably would have taken him. But after Prescott's Game Day Ready 7-11 commercial, I think it's clear Dak is the better QB.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Members online

Total: 640 (members: 33, guests: 607)

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
465,455
Messages
13,876,021
Members
23,791
Latest member
mashburn
Back
Top