If you could take one player (not QBs) from the Giants, Eagles and Commanders

[HappyOnions]

If you could take any player from each of our division rivals who would it be and more importantly, do you think we would have made the playoffs with those 3 guys?

Giants - Victor Cruz (stretches the field better than Miles or Terrance Williams)
Commanders - Brian Orakpo (would have been so helpful to have during our linebacker drought)
Eagles - Fletcher Cox (Young, promising defensive lineman who would have easily brought more pressure)

Playoffs easily for us if we had these three guys.

 

[DallasEast]

Eagles: Fletcher Cox
Giants: Jason Pierre-Paul
Commanders: Perry Riley

Edit: No, I do not believe that we would have made the playoffs with these players added to the roster. There were too many key mistakes committed by players and coaches during most of the eight losses to overcome.

 

[Doomsday]

Giants - Linval Joseph
Commanders - Pierre Garcon
Eagles - Fletcher Cox

 

[Neverhood]

Kerrigan, McCoy, and no giants, they all suck

 

[KingintheNorth]

Eagles: DeSean Jackson. I'm like a jilted lover with this player. USC should have had him, Cowboys should have had him.
Commanders: Trent Williams. Hate everyone on that team but he's their best player.
Giants: JPP. Freak pass rusher.

 

[dstovall5]

I'd take -

Eagles - Chip Kelley or Lesean McCoy
Commanders - Pierre Garçon
Giants - JPP

And for torture in return I'd give -

Eagles - Jason Garret
Commanders - Stephen Jones
Giants - Jerry Jones

 

[HappyOnions]

Giants - Linval Joseph
Commanders - Pierre Garcon
Eagles - Fletcher Cox

Pierre Garcon over Kerrigan or Orakpo? Interesting.

 

[Hardline]

Giants. JPP
Eagles. McCoy
Commanders. Orakpo

 

[ChooChoo73]

Garcon
McCoy
JPP
No playoffs. 2 of the three would be out with hamstrings and our depth would still be atrocious.

 

[mitchell2254]

Eagles - LeSean Mccoy
Commanders - Trent Williams
Giants - JPP

 

[diehard2294]

Easy one

Giants Rolle
Eagles Shady
Commanders Hall so he can't cover Dez anymore

 

[theogt]

Fletcher Cox over McCoy? Really?

 

[Christiann]

McCoy
JPP
Kerrigan

1A would be Kendricks

 

[Novacek84]

Eagles: McCoy (the only Eagle I've actually ever liked)
Giants: Eli (because I don't believe Romo will ever win here. Good player, gives 110% but too much baggage to overcome with our fan base)
Commanders: Trent Williams (put him at RT and pair with Tyron)

 

[cowboys1981]

JPP
McCoy
Williams

 

[ABQCOWBOY]

Victor Cruz - Giants
Trent Williams - Commanders
Shady - Eagles

 

[Lonestar94]

Giants - Pierre Paul
Commanders - Ryan Kerrigan
Eagles - Cary Williams

 

[The Natural]

DeMeco Ryans
Antrell Rolle
Brian Orakpo

I know Orakpo is more of the 3-4 OLB but I believe he could play end in a 4-3. I upgraded each level of our defense, talent wise we'd be better but cant say it would've been enough to make the playoffs due to the head coach. I understand the McCoy love he's a good player but sub him for Murray and we're still watching the games from home today.

 

[Nation]

JPP, Fletcher Cox, and Trent Williams

 

[blindzebra]

Lane Johnson slightly over McCoy

JJP

Kerrigan