If you could take one player (not QBs) from the Giants, Eagles and Commanders

[Novacek84]

Eagles: McCoy (the only Eagle I've actually ever liked)
Giants: Eli (because I don't believe Romo will ever win here. Good player, gives 110% but too much baggage to overcome with our fan base)
Commanders: Trent Williams (put him at RT and pair with Tyron)

Whoops missed the non QB part. So on NYG give me Cruz, I guess.

 

[Section446]

Eagles: Jason Peters.
Commanders: Trent Williams.
Giants: Victor Cruz.

 

[Questfor6]

Eagles: Mychal Kendricks-all over the field

Giants: Linval Joseph- space eater in the middle but always provides good pressure.

Skins: Kerrigan-relentless on his pass rush, doesn't breakdown like Orakpo.

 

[Oh_Canada]

Phi-Kendricks
NYG-JPP
Wash-Trent Williams

 

[TanneyTrouble]

Giants: Linval Joseph
Commanders: Barry Coefield
Iggles: Evan Mathis

 

[Plankton]

Eagles - Fletcher Cox - has the potential to be a good 3T under Marinelli's tutelage. While McCoy is awesome, and an obvious choice, he'd be wasted in the Cowboy offense.
Commanders - Ryan Kerrigan - would be a solid end. Orakpo is too injury prone.
Giants - Antrel Rolle - instant upgrade at free safety.

 

[HappyOnions]

Fletcher Cox over McCoy? Really?

Murray is good enough to warrant passing on McCoy... out defensive line is not good enough to warrant passing on anyone; especially Fletcher Cox

 

[Cowboy Brian]

JPP is a no brainer.
Trent Williams
Cox

Yes playoffs with these three

 

[Szczepanik]

Rolle off the G-Men. No more heath.

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

If you could take any player from each of our division rivals who would it be and more importantly, do you think we would have made the playoffs with those 3 guys?

Giants - Victor Cruz (stretches the field better than Miles or Terrance Williams)
Commanders - Brian Orakpo (would have been so helpful to have during our linebacker drought)
Eagles - Fletcher Cox (Young, promising defensive lineman who would have easily brought more pressure)

Playoffs easily for us if we had these three guys.

Eagles - Shady McCoy
Skins - Kerrigan
Giants - antrel rolle

 

[Pessimist_cowboy]

Fletcher Cox over McCoy? Really?

Lol comical isn't it ?

 

[Tolstrup]

JPP, McCoy and Kerrigan

 

[hra8700]

Eagles - LeSean Mccoy
Commanders - Trent Williams
Giants - JPP

ding ding ding. Only real options on nyg are cruz and jpp. Id take jpp by a margin. Only real option on eagles is mccoy...by far their best young player. Same for Commanders and trent williams.

Although rg3 and foles would def be options as promising young qbs...position is just too valuable.

 

[CaptainCreed]

I know this is not the point of this thread but I notice a lot of former Cowboys leaving here for free agency and going to division rivals, Chris Canty, Stephen Bowen, Dan Connor, Felix Jones just recently. The only guys in the last ten years to leave the skins, Eagles, or Giants and come to the boys that I can name off the top of my head are Kyle Bosworth, and TO but not really any division rival draft picks coming to Dallas for 2nd contracts. Do players really hate the Cowboys that much?

 

[CooterBrown]

Eagles-Kendricks
Giants-JPP
Commanders-Kerrigan

Bolster the front seven.

 

[CowboysLegend365]

I'd take -

Eagles - Chip Kelley or Lesean McCoy
Commanders - Pierre Garçon
Giants - JPP

And for torture in return I'd give -

Eagles - Jason Garret
Commanders - Stephen Jones
Giants - Jerry Jones

Jerry Jones in NY would be hilarious.

 

[jterrell]

Kendricks ---young, cheap ascending player at need position
Rolle ---Biggest need
Trent Williams ---form best bookends in football.

McCoy is a tool and also a RB which hinders his value,
Kendricks over Cox was tough call. Crawford nudged it to the LB.

 

[Cowboyz88]

Every time I see McCoy's name, I cringe, knowing that we had a first round grade on him and passed.

Nice job GM Jerry!

 

[big dog cowboy]

LOL at guys picking offense players.

 

[Doomsday]

Pierre Garcon over Kerrigan or Orakpo? Interesting.

Yea, Kerrigan is always hurt and Im not sure Orakpo fits our scheme. I was thinking Trent Williams or Garcon to give us a legit #2 who can stretch the field.