Jayden Daniels is better than Dak

[NFCBeasts]

Dak was not the highest paid player in the league. The previous eight seasons. What was causing the inability up to this point?

Short memory for you ? Dak was the first 40 million dollar a year qb when he signed that deal … what more do you want for him? Josh Allen finds ways to win with no name receivers why can’t Dak?

 

[NFCBeasts]

I do not disagree, yet here we are. This contract has destroyed this team for the next 5 years

But it makes 20% of the fans here happy who cares about deep playoff runs

 

[Ken]

But he showed natural talent & abilities. Test for those came back negative on #4.

AKA the "Eye test"

Other notable graduates of the "Eye Test"

Trevor Lawrence
Justin Herbert
Justin Fields
etc etc etc

 

[McKDaddy]

AKA the "Eye test"

Other notable graduates of the "Eye Test"

Trevor Lawrence
Justin Herbert
Justin Fields
etc etc etc

What other test is there for things like poise in the pocket, good decision making, having the arm talent to make top level throws, having the mental makeup to make those throws even with the D in great position, etc.?

If you don't like the eye test on him, feel free to look at the stats from Monday night.

FWIW - I have never been fervent fan of either Trevor or Fields. Herbert is bona fide. If you can't see his talent, might want to get your eyes checked. Before anyone chimes in with any silliness, his organization has been crap & he's had some unfortunate injuries but his talent is recognized by players, coaches, GM's as being up there with Mahomes.

 

[Ken]

What other test is there for things like poise in the pocket, good decision making, having the arm talent to make top level throws, having the mental makeup to make those throws even with the D in great position, etc.?

If you don't like the eye test on him, feel free to look at the stats from Monday night.

FWIW - I have never been fervent fan of either Trevor or Fields. Herbert is bona fide. If you can't see his talent, might want to get your eyes checked. Before anyone chimes in with any silliness, his organization has been crap & he's had some unfortunate injuries but his talent is recognized by players, coaches, GM's as being up there with Mahomes.

We can all see the talent...we can't see the top level qbing that is needed to be one of the best.

A coach once said...talent will get you beat. Talent and playing g the position at a high level are two different things.

 

[DandyDon52]

Oh, so winning a few regular season games counts as success for these other QBs???

Dallas has won 12 games each of the last 3 years, but Dak has to win playoff games to earn your respect. Got it.

Yet Andy Dalton beating the Raiders in Week 3 means something to you??? Hilarious.


"Da Seahawks can't run da ball either!"

Just say you don't watch teams besides the Cowboys. Don't embarrass yourself like this. Seahawks run game has been very good in 2 of their 3 games.

IF these other qb's go 12-5 3 years in a row but cant get past the div round, fans would feel the same about them as they
do dak.
Winning games in the regular season matters, but if a team/qb consistently flops in playoffs, they will get a bad rep.

About dalton , he won with a team that was considered the worst in the league, they went to him as qb and boom they not only won but
looked good. He made a big difference in carolina .They lost to cin, but it was close game. Time will tell us more on them.

 

[lk8701]

What other test is there for things like poise in the pocket, good decision making, having the arm talent to make top level throws, having the mental makeup to make those throws even with the D in great position, etc.?

If you don't like the eye test on him, feel free to look at the stats from Monday night.

FWIW - I have never been fervent fan of either Trevor or Fields. Herbert is bona fide. If you can't see his talent, might want to get your eyes checked. Before anyone chimes in with any silliness, his organization has been crap & he's had some unfortunate injuries but his talent is recognized by players, coaches, GM's as being up there with Mahomes.

Agreed. The eye test isn't hard to comprehend. Dak's talent level is on par with Carr and Cousins. He has had the good fortune of playing with better talent around him.