Jerry Rice: Garoppolo Better Than Dak

[GenoT]

Let the fun begin...

https://www.nbcsports.com/bayarea/49ers/49ers-jimmy-garoppolo-better-qb-dak-prescott-jerry-rice-says

 

[CATCH17]

They're similar.

Dak's had better offensive talent around him that elevates him but poor coaching.

Jimmy G has had mediocre offensive talent around him but great coaching.

 

[JohnnyHopkins]

Wow, that is a serious 49ers homer statement right there!

 

[Established1971]

Not outrageous
Im a believer in qb rating. Dak career 97. Jimmy 100.0
Jimmy took a team to a SB. Dak hasnt gotten to the conference game
Its close at this point. But I wouldnt be at all surprised if Dak was much better in 2020 than him. We shall see.

Now the Dak slobbers will hone in on only certain words in my comment and get mad, when in fact I made a balanced comment.

 

[CATCH17]

Not outrageous
Im a believer in qb rating. Dak career 97. Jimmy 100.0
Jimmy took a team to a SB. Dak hasnt gotten to the conference game
Its close at this point. But I wouldnt be at all surprised if Dak was much better in 2020 than him. We shall see.

Now the Dak slobbers will hone in on only certain words in my comment and get mad, when in fact I made a balanced comment.

Jimmy G, like Dak, is just along for the ride and depends on others to carry him places.

 

[Hennessy_King]

Not outrageous
Im a believer in qb rating. Dak career 97. Jimmy 100.0
Jimmy took a team to a SB. Dak hasnt gotten to the conference game
Its close at this point. But I wouldnt be at all surprised if Dak was much better in 2020 than him. We shall see.

Now the Dak slobbers will hone in on only certain words in my comment and get mad, when in fact I made a balanced comment.

San fran had the 2nd best defense in the league last year. And a phenomenal run game. Jimmy G was a non factor. He was dilferesque last season.

 

[Hennessy_King]

Jimmy G, like Dak, is just along for the ride and depends on others to carry him places.

Dak was the best player on the team last year on both sides of the ball.

 

[Future]

Dak is so much better than Jimmy it's not even funny.

Jimmy was near the bottom of the league in air yards, and at the top in YAC. Dak was the exact opposite. Jimmy's numbers are entirely the product of that scheme.

 

[HappyOnions]

They're pretty comparable but Jimmy G has a much better W/L ratio and can actually beat the PACKERS...

I think its a wash between them, although if forced to choose, I'd give Jimmy G the nod because of how far he's led his team.

 

[Bullflop]

Not outrageous
Im a believer in qb rating. Dak career 97. Jimmy 100.0
Jimmy took a team to a SB. Dak hasnt gotten to the conference game
Its close at this point. But I wouldnt be at all surprised if Dak was much better in 2020 than him. We shall see.

Now the Dak slobbers will hone in on only certain words in my comment and get mad, when in fact I made a balanced comment.

I'm inclined to agree with that rating. I've long felt Garoppolo was better than Dak but didn't think it was that close. They're both good.

 

[HappyOnions]

Dak is so much better than Jimmy it's not even funny.

Jimmy was near the bottom of the league in air yards, and at the top in YAC. Dak was the exact opposite. Jimmy's numbers are entirely the product of that scheme.

To be fair, Dak accumulated most of his numbers against trash teams.

We all watched the same games last year... its hard to deny

 

[Kingofholland]

I think we should have Michael Irvin weigh in on this too. Thinking he would go Dak, lol.

I love Irvin and Rice, but I suspect there will always be bias towards the teams they played for. The NFL top 100 has Dak at 46 and Jimmy at 43 so guess according to that vote Jimmy a couple cms better. The 49ers had everything come together for them last year and made it to the Super Bowl and almost won it despite some pretty pedistrian performances from Jimmy.

 

[SteveTheCowboy]

Dak is so much better than Jimmy it's not even funny.

Jimmy was near the bottom of the league in air yards, and at the top in YAC. Dak was the exact opposite. Jimmy's numbers are entirely the product of that scheme.

I can;t seem to find the YAC stat. A little help?

 

[SteveTheCowboy]

To be fair, Dak accumulated most of his numbers against trash teams.

We all watched the same games last year... its hard to deny

A lot of people do deny it. In looking to the YAC stat...I found this:
(I hope I am not violating any rule....I posted a link once and got a warning. Please forgive me mods and just delete if necessary. I feel this is an important link to back up Mr. Onions)

"Now is not the time to celebrate Dak the passer, because the more the Cowboys lose, the more his NFL-best stats are exposed as garbage time buckets."

https://www.star-telegram.com/sports/spt-columns-blogs/mac-engel/article238104579.html

 

[Vanilla2]

If there’s one thing Rice will know it’s a system qb

 

[Future]

To be fair, Dak accumulated most of his numbers against trash teams.

We all watched the same games last year... its hard to deny

Lol ok now go do that for Jimmy.

 

[Wood]

Let the fun begin...

https://www.nbcsports.com/bayarea/49ers/49ers-jimmy-garoppolo-better-qb-dak-prescott-jerry-rice-says

I think he is right and I believe Garoppolo is only making $28 mill year. That's problem with entire Dak contract negotiations is that Garoppolo is fair comparison but Dak and his agent see himself as top 5.

 

[Doomsday101]

It is a big help to any QB and the offense, when your defense can get the ball back in your hands off turnovers. SF managed 27 take aways to the Cowboys 17.

 

[Future]

I can;t seem to find the YAC stat. A little help?

I think it's PFF but I don't subscribe.
From Twitter but edited for language
Dak Prescott aDOT: 9.3 (5th) YAC/CMP: 4.9 (25tg) 25% PA Yards Deep Accuracy: 54.72% (6th) 0.23 EPA/P 70.20 QBR
Jimmy Garoppolo aDOT: 6.5 (31st) YAC/CMP: 6.6 (1st) 36% PA Yards Deep Accuracy: 51.82% (10th) 0.22 EPA/P 58.80 QBR

 

[NumOneQB]

Hmmm, a 49er saying a 49er is better than a Cowboy?