Why is it dumb? Here's just a few reasons:
- Teams did stack 8 in the box against the Cowboys…a lot. We’ve seen it all of the time thru articles like Ben Muth’s on Football Outsiders. They put 8 in the box because they knew we were not a threat in the passing game with our backup QB’s and no Dez. Per usual, JJT is just making stuff up. Must have had a deadline to fulfill.
- Having a tailback that ‘commands’ 8 in the box is not a ‘philosophy.’ Every team would like to have a back that commands 8 in the box. Unfortunately, you can’t just get a tailback that is going to command that every time. It’s dependent up on your O-Line and your passing game as well.
- Morris is an adept zone running back (provided he still has some juice in those legs). DMC was better in man blocking. Having both tailbacks helps us be able to switch between zone and man blocking. THAT would go along with our philosophy of being a versatile running team that can use both zone and man blocking schemes along with being able to run left, right and up the middle.
We won in 2014 because we balanced out the offense. We were almost at 50/50 in terms of running and passing. We took the ball out of Romo's hands so he didn't have to throw it so much and that allowed him to be more effective. But, without Romo (and Dez), we simply do not run the ball anywhere nearly as effective because teams just stack the box. For instance, in the 2nd game against Philly in 2014, the Eagles stacked the box and blitzed almost the entire game. Murray had something like 31 carries for 83 yards (IIRC). But we scored a ton of points because it made it easier for Romo. Without Romo teams could just stack the box without any fear and stop the run. And even still, only Adrian Peterson ran the ball better in those last 10 games that McFadden started. And I'm not a huge Bridgewater fan, but he's far better than Weeden, Cassel and Moore.
If anything, JJT wasn't watching the games very carefully to see what the opposing defenses were doing. Dumb, ignorant, incompetent...call it whatever you want.
YR