Joe Judge Fired

[nate dizzle]

That would be the last situation I’d want to be in. Questionable QB and virtually no talent.

They have a ton of picks in this year's draft. Two top 10 picks and like 3 or 4 in the 3rd iirc.

 

[AmericanCowboy]

They have a ton of picks in this year's draft. Two top 10 picks and like 3 or 4 in the 3rd iirc.

Yeah, honestly, If I were Kellen Moore this is an extremely attractive position. It really just depends on if he wants to deal with the media, but any HC is going to deal with the Media.

He would be replacing three awful head coaches before him, so the bar is incredibly low to begin with. You never want to replace a beloved figure in any organization, it is difficult to follow in their footsteps.......The Giants just fired 3 coaches in the last 6 years, so most likely if he is at least somewhat competent he is going to last longer. If he is somewhat competent the fans will love him.

The coaches before him all seem incredibly rude and unlikeable, and so simply by him being respectful to others he is going to be loved by the organization.

He already knows the division extremely well and knows their biggest rival the best.

Awesome draft picks. This would be the one I would be concerned about.

 

[RustyBourneHorse]

Huge bummer.

I was hoping they'd keep him another year.

He was an awful Head Coach.

Don't worry, I reckon Jason Garrett will be their next HC. This is exactly what he wanted. It shows that it wasn't his fault, which he can play to ownership there and say at least they had an offense while he was there.

 

[DandyDon52]

So, does this mean they announce Red Jesus as HC on Friday? Or will Garrett be the GM?

lol they should hurry, and go ahead and get the "Process" started !!

 

[DandyDon52]

Yeah, honestly, If I were Kellen Moore this is an extremely attractive position. It really just depends on if he wants to deal with the media, but any HC is going to deal with the Media.

He would be replacing three awful head coaches before him, so the bar is incredibly low to begin with. You never want to replace a beloved figure in any organization, it is difficult to follow in their footsteps.......The Giants just fired 3 coaches in the last 6 years, so most likely if he is at least somewhat competent he is going to last longer. If he is somewhat competent the fans will love him.

The coaches before him all seem incredibly rude and unlikeable, and so simply by him being respectful to others he is going to be loved by the organization.

He already knows the division extremely well and knows their biggest rival the best.

Awesome draft picks. This would be the one I would be concerned about.

good points.

 

[khiladi]

People act like nobody would take the Jacksonville job, let alone something as prestigious as coaching in NY. Guys spend their whole lives dreaming of the day to be a HC and guys will line up for them. The only difference right now is that there are so many openings, these guys are in a better position to choose a destination they prefer.

If you can turn around a Jaguars team, you instantly become a legend. If you win in NY, it’s a whole different level. Plus, with modern free agency it’s a lot different, which is why expectations to win early are not like they used to be.

 

[khiladi]

He was doomed the day he agreed to having Garrett as his OC.

It was kind of forced on him by Mara. It was similar to the Wade situation here, where the Garrett family had really close ties to the owner and family.

 

[BotchedLobotomy]

There's a lot of openings now. No way we keep our coordinators. Gotta win now.

A lot of openings, but not many are desirable unless you just want to be a HC for a couple of years.

 

[Reverend Conehead]

Gee, what a shock.

 

[LittleLexodus]

Incredible lol

Joe Judge set back the NYG franchise years. Those fans have got to feel good about this news

 

[RustyBourneHorse]

lol they should hurry, and go ahead and get the "Process" started !!

Or maybe....they take.....the Urban Legend hehe.

 

[DandyDon52]

Or maybe....they take.....the Urban Legend hehe.

I think Urban is done in nfl lol

 

[RustyBourneHorse]

I think Urban is done in nfl lol

I expect so, but hey, it'd be good fun if the Giants did hire him.

 

[Zordon]

A lot of openings, but not many are desirable unless you just want to be a HC for a couple of years.

Desirable jobs are not usually firing their head coaches.

 

[sdfidaho]

Thank you, Jesus….this news is both a surprise and much needed. Judge embarrassed himself and our team especially the past month.

Now I hope we hire a very smart GM who knows football, player evaluation, and knows how to surround himself with good sharp people to help him. Go Giants!

You can have Jerry Jones. He fits all those criteria……just ask him

 

[PhillyCowboysFan]

What a mistake hiring Judge was. Mara needs to call Parcells for counsel, hire a real GM and get out of the way.

Just a question. I know that Parcels is a wealth of football knowledge, but is it past his time to have a good feel of the game to give recommendations?

 

[NotForLong]

 

[nightrain]

Just a question. I know that Parcels is a wealth of football knowledge, but is it past his time to have a good feel of the game to give recommendations?

I think at this stage it's more about process and how to evaluate and select personnel. Parcells always had a robust staff of talented coaches on the sideline with him. He is true football guy if there ever was one.

 

[BotchedLobotomy]

Desirable jobs are not usually firing their head coaches.

Totally disagree. Are you saying that when the Cowboys canned Carrot that this job was not desirable?

 

[8FOR!3]

It was kind of forced on him by Mara. It was similar to the Wade situation here, where the Garrett family had really close ties to the owner and family.

we’re really blaming Garrett over the giants coach that lied about former players calling wanting to return to NY?