Kaiser Rolls out quick analysis

Kaiser

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,628
Reaction score
28,430
It sucks but its just one game. This team looked to be something like 9 – 7 anyway so there are plenty of opportunities for these things to even out.

On the loss, give the Giants credit for a smart game plan and executing it well. They took away Dez and the running game (thought I thought Zeke would still do much better against a stacked D) and make a rookie QB beat them – which is very nearly did. Dallas wins this game if they convert one of the first three field goals into a TD, and that is something that will come when timing and execution improve.

Dallas also wins the game if Twill gets out of bounds. There is no excuse for that play, none, zero. Even if he puts up a good season statistically, that is the kind of play that could cause Dallas to let him leave in FA.


The big obvious plus is Dak Prescott. He looked like he was born to play this game, most rookies in their first game are completely lost no matter how much talent they have. Romo’s first game was three years into his career and he still make plenty of mistakes. Eli Manning’s first start as a rookie looked like a drunk giraffe playing hopscotch. Tom Brady only had three passing attempts as a true rookie.

A good example is that even as a true rookie, Dak knows when to throw the ball away. It took Romo two years (as a starter) to learn to do that and not try to force the ball attempting a big play.

He would also stay calm with the pocket breaking down, a lot of young QBs will spring outside or start running, while Dak just sidesteps a few feet so the receivers don’t break off their routes. It’s a small thing, but a big one. For a rookie, its really something. Also I think Dak only had one bad throw all day, about the same number 13 year pro Eli Manning had.

This defense isn’t good, but its good enough. The season will look just like this (and like 2014), the offense controls the game and the defense plays containment.

McClain looked good and the safeties were quiet – which is a huge improvement over Wilcox getting burned once a quarter.

The DLine is the obvious concern, missing DLaw takes out our best pass rusher and Tapper is needed for rotation depth so we don’t have Wilbur taking DE snaps like a fish out of water. Jack Crawford is an above average backup 3T but a below average LDE, but he is the only one we have at the moment. David Irving is obviously hurt worse than they let on, he only played a few series.

Overall, this is a team that still needs to gell and one that desperately needs its DL to be healthy and/or reinstated. But its still a playoff caliber team.
 

Nightman

Capologist
Messages
27,121
Reaction score
24,038
It sucks but its just one game. This team looked to be something like 9 – 7 anyway so there are plenty of opportunities for these things to even out.

On the loss, give the Giants credit for a smart game plan and executing it well. They took away Dez and the running game (thought I thought Zeke would still do much better against a stacked D) and make a rookie QB beat them – which is very nearly did. Dallas wins this game if they convert one of the first three field goals into a TD, and that is something that will come when timing and execution improve.

Dallas also wins the game if Twill gets out of bounds. There is no excuse for that play, none, zero. Even if he puts up a good season statistically, that is the kind of play that could cause Dallas to let him leave in FA.


The big obvious plus is Dak Prescott. He looked like he was born to play this game, most rookies in their first game are completely lost no matter how much talent they have. Romo’s first game was three years into his career and he still make plenty of mistakes. Eli Manning’s first start as a rookie looked like a drunk giraffe playing hopscotch. Tom Brady only had three passing attempts as a true rookie.

A good example is that even as a true rookie, Dak knows when to throw the ball away. It took Romo two years (as a starter) to learn to do that and not try to force the ball attempting a big play.

He would also stay calm with the pocket breaking down, a lot of young QBs will spring outside or start running, while Dak just sidesteps a few feet so the receivers don’t break off their routes. It’s a small thing, but a big one. For a rookie, its really something. Also I think Dak only had one bad throw all day, about the same number 13 year pro Eli Manning had.

This defense isn’t good, but its good enough. The season will look just like this (and like 2014), the offense controls the game and the defense plays containment.

McClain looked good and the safeties were quiet – which is a huge improvement over Wilcox getting burned once a quarter.

The DLine is the obvious concern, missing DLaw takes out our best pass rusher and Tapper is needed for rotation depth so we don’t have Wilbur taking DE snaps like a fish out of water. Jack Crawford is an above average backup 3T but a below average LDE, but he is the only one we have at the moment. David Irving is obviously hurt worse than they let on, he only played a few series.

Overall, this is a team that still needs to gell and one that desperately needs its DL to be healthy and/or reinstated. But its still a playoff caliber team.
EE- fine, no blocking at all
Dak- has IT, is a star
DL- atrocious
TWill- disagree, we needed yards too
 

Irvin88_4life

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,509
Reaction score
26,396
EE- fine, no blocking at all
Dak- has IT, is a star
DL- atrocious
TWill- disagree, we needed yards too
Bailey has made 60 plus in practice. Given that it was indoors given him a chance at 60 plus would be better then not giving him a shot.

If Bailey gets a chance it might miss but he might make it. Not getting that chance is a for sure loss
 

Nightman

Capologist
Messages
27,121
Reaction score
24,038
Bailey has made 60 plus in practice. Given that it was indoors given him a chance at 60 plus would be better then not giving him a shot.

If Bailey gets a chance it might miss but he might make it. Not getting that chance is a for sure loss
and TWill took a shot at getting the first and clocking the ball.... he came up short just like Bailey might
 

Rogerthat12

DWAREZ
Messages
14,605
Reaction score
9,989
I just think this defense will continue to be exploited especially by teams like GB, PITT and the Bengals.

They simply do not have the horses to hang with better offenses, there were times today that Giants ran at will and we could not stop it!

The ends provided little pressure and the push we were hoping for in the middle was inconsistent and underwhelming.

Lawrence will certainly help when he gets back but I simply do not think that it will be enough.

They should have added some more substantial DE talent in free agency but failed to and it showed!
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,731
Reaction score
95,252
EE- fine, no blocking at all
Dak- has IT, is a star
DL- atrocious
TWill- disagree, we needed yards too

What?

At that point, yards are secondary to getting out of bounds. There was only like 12 seconds on the clock when the ball was snapped. Fighting for extra yardage is about as dumb as one can get in that situation.
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,731
Reaction score
95,252
and TWill took a shot at getting the first and clocking the ball.... he came up short just like Bailey might

There is no way you can do all of that in 12 seconds. That's a brain dead play by Williams. It just is. It takes the refs anywhere from 6-8 seconds to get the ball and reset it.
 

percyhoward

Research Tool
Messages
17,062
Reaction score
21,861
This defense isn’t good, but its good enough. The season will look just like this (and like 2014), the offense controls the game and the defense plays containment.
The defense (2.22 points allowed per drive) wasn't as good as 2014 (1.89) or 2015 (1.99). Needed to hold them to a FG on one of those red zone possessions.

The good news is that if the defense had played up to its form of the last two seasons, Dak was good enough to win, even with two dropped TD.
 

Nightman

Capologist
Messages
27,121
Reaction score
24,038
What?

At that point, yards are secondary to getting out of bounds. There was only like 12 seconds on the clock when the ball was snapped. Fighting for extra yardage is about as dumb as one can get in that situation.
he took a shot........a 65 yd FG is a risk too
 

Nightman

Capologist
Messages
27,121
Reaction score
24,038
There is no way you can do all of that in 14 seconds. That's a brain dead play by Williams. It just is. It takes the refs anywhere from 8-10 seconds to get the ball and reset it.
they only missed clocking it by as second
 

Tommy

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,221
Reaction score
2,982
EE- fine, no blocking at all
Dak- has IT, is a star
DL- atrocious
TWill- disagree, we needed yards too
What are you talking about? TWill got tackled and it ended the game. We needed those yards?
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,731
Reaction score
95,252
he took a shot........a 65 yd FG is a risk too

Took a shot at what? Getting 3 extra yards with no time on the clock?

Anyone who thinks he made the right move needs their heads examined. The ball was snapped with 12 seconds left. You need at least 6 seconds for the refs to spot the ball so you can spike it. There's no way that play took less than 6 seconds to run.
 

Teague31

Defender of the Star
Messages
18,221
Reaction score
22,842
The run D was much much worse than I thought it would be. And the Giants OL isn't exactly stellar
 

Irvin88_4life

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,509
Reaction score
26,396
and TWill took a shot at getting the first and clocking the ball.... he came up short just like Bailey might
Wasn't enough time to spike it. Getting out of bounds and give Bailey a chance to kick it is much better then getting tackle in bounds and game over. Bailey might miss but I have more faith in Bailey making it then Williams getting down in time
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,731
Reaction score
95,252
they only missed clocking it by as second

One second, 5 seconds, doesn't matter. They couldn't get the snap off............... and that's because Williams went stupid and didn't make an effort to get out of bounds.

I am usually with you on most things about this team but this one is out in left field. It was a boneheaded decision.
 

CWR

Well-Known Member
Messages
25,443
Reaction score
37,106
and TWill took a shot at getting the first and clocking the ball.... he came up short just like Bailey might

Im sorry man Twill had two objectives there; catch the ball and get out of bounds. He blew it plain and simple. Low football IQ at its best right there. Everyone knew we didnt have enough time to clock it.
 

plymkr

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,385
Reaction score
15,496
EE- he played well being his first game and they keyed on him. Morris ran better but our coaches decided to stop doing what works to avoid the victory

Dak- Is the next franchise QB, we can win with him

DL- sucks, sucks, sucks, it's laughable how bad they suck

Twill- invisible without Romo, only makes an appearance to make a bad play

Secondary- We're not getting what we pay for. Carr and Mo are the equivalent to the DL but in CB form. They're just jokes at this point. safeties played decent.

LBers- worthless, they round up the front 7 just fine to make the defense below average

Receivers- dropped the ball, literally and metaphorically. This season I personally may have to come to grips that Romo might be done cuz of injuries and Dez is fading fast. Witten catches everything thrown to him but coaches decided to try and turn him into a speedster today. Didn't work so we kept doing it to make sure it won't work. Don't be surprised to see that be a staple of Garret's offense now that we know it won't work.

Alfred Morris- ran the ball well in his limited time and kept drives alive. Unfortunately Garret saw this and made the adjustment to take Morris out of the game ASAP and continued to pound the ball with EE and his 2.0 yards per carry. Don't be surprised to see Morris completely wiped from Garret's playbook and possibly cut tomorrow because of his production.

Coaches- see Alfred Morris and receivers.
 

Nightman

Capologist
Messages
27,121
Reaction score
24,038
all the options sucked.......the game was over before he caught the ball
 

Kevinicus

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,886
Reaction score
12,670
Bailey has made 60 plus in practice. Given that it was indoors given him a chance at 60 plus would be better then not giving him a shot.

If Bailey gets a chance it might miss but he might make it. Not getting that chance is a for sure loss

Every kicker in the league has surely made 60+ yarders in practice. The kicker at my high school made a 73 yarder at practice. It's much different when there is a rush though.
 

Sydla

Well-Known Member
Messages
61,731
Reaction score
95,252
all the options sucked.......the game was over before he caught the ball

You are just covering for Williams.

There were no "great" options. But lining Bailey up for a 60 yard FG is a better option than a WR trying to get 3 extra yards with only 12 seconds left on the clock when the play started and no timeouts.

You must be a big Williams fan. That's the only thing I can come up with as to how someone could defend what he did there.
 
Top