Switz;3322585 said:
I was watching one of those top 10 lists this one was top 10 one shot wonders on the NFL network. Larry Brown was 3 I think maybe 4 never this less. He shoudl not have even been on this listed. He played in 3 superbowls had a Ok career. all time leader with Harvery Martin for Ints in superbowls with 3... Yes he had another int in a superbowl other than the 2 vs Pittsburgh. This guy actually had some solid games vs good WR like Jerry Rice. I am not saying by any stretch he was Deion Sanders.. but to be on a list with Timmy Smith and some guys who was QB for the Bengals in the 60's is just stupid.
I didn't see it but that would have to be Greg Cook. He was the top rated passer as a rookie! He wrecked his shoulder during the season and was never the same. The kid could have had an amazing career if not for that injury.
If you look up his stats they won't wow you unless you look at his average per attempt which was 9.4! That's 8th all-time for a season and he was a rookie! You also have to remember that the leagues (NFL & AFL) were mostly run-oriented at that time.
He was a big kid at 6'4" 220 lbs and could run as well as pass. This was also only the 2nd year of the Bengals' existence so they didn't exactly have an all-star team surrounding him. He had great touch on his deep passes and could rifle the ball when needed.
I only remember watching one game he played, against the Chargers. He threw for 327 yards and 3 TDs and ran for another TD as they beat San Diego 34-20. The kid looked like a 10-year veteran out there and the Chargers were a good team but it was only his 2nd start.
Paul Brown was the HC and Bill Walsh was one of the assistant coaches at the time. They agreed that Cook could have been one of the best ever. The fact that he started 8 games AFTER he tore his rotator cuff is amazing!
Without a doubt one of the greatest "might-have-beens" of all time.
Note: Dr. Z lists Cook's 1969 season as one of "The 13 best single-season QB performances of all time":
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2004/writers/dr_z/12/12/top.qb.seasons/
Granted that was written in 2004 but still...