Wouldn't really matter since Zimmer is our DCOord.
Who's to say Roy wouldn't be 5X as good if we had a DCoord that knew how to use him?
So it's hard to say. It would be hard to pass on Freeney either way. Freeney could help turn an average secondary into a good secondary, or good to great.
I also wouldn't of been against trading down more and taking Reed. He would of been a better fit at the time anyway (with Woodson at SS, Reed would of been a nice compliment as a FS).
That said, I love Roy. I think despite Zimmer, he's still a solid safety. If we had a Dick Lebeau he'd probably easily be considered the best Safety in the NFL.