Malik McDowell

xwalker

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
58,306
Reaction score
66,476
Nothing new per se but this is a recent article.

https://www.___GET_REAL_URL___/s/ww...-health-reports-have-any-cowboys-move-on-hold
 
It sounds like the medical reports are mixed but the Seahawks front office thinks they will get sued if they clear him to play and he immediately has a career ending injury.
 
Kaiser said:
It sounds like the medical reports are mixed but the Seahawks front office thinks they will get sued if they clear him to play and he immediately has a career ending injury.
Click to expand...

I was just about to ask, why didn't Seattle just put him on injured reserve. This is quite the conundrum here...
 
Carroll's basically called him damaged goods (in the eyes of their doctors). Doesn't that violate HIPPA rules in some way? I'm sure Malik's camp wasn't thrilled by Carroll's quotes? Or were the quotes vague enough that there was no violation at all?

Someone please enlighten me, I'm really not familiar with how HIPPA works.
 
Rosenhaus got Willis Mcgahee a first round draft pick after serious thought to be career ending knee injury.

If Rosenhaus is still in on McDowell, the Cowboys maybe still in. This is a liability issue as football is a collision sport and the NFL has had a lot of bad press regarding head injuries.
 
Hailmary said:
Carroll's basically called him damaged goods (in the eyes of their doctors). Doesn't that violate HIPPA rules in some way? I'm sure Malik's camp wasn't thrilled by Carroll's quotes? Or were the quotes vague enough that there was no violation at all?

Someone please enlighten me, I'm really not familiar with how HIPPA works.
Click to expand...

Carroll just said their Doctors couldn't clear him. He didn't give out any medical details.

The players union and the league have guidelines defined in the CBA that allows basic information to be released/discussed which other employers wouldn't be allowed to disclose.
 
The Seahawks doctors wouldn't clear him but another "group" of doctors did. Was there a serious head injury involved? Unsure of what the injuries were or the severity. Have to trust the Cowboys doctors on this one. I'm sure he wants to play football again but how much risk to playing again? We have very little information.
 
hope we clear him.
he was on my "want-list" for that draft.
very intrigued.
won't happen over night but I hope he is able to giver' a go.
 
CF74 said:
I was just about to ask, why didn't Seattle just put him on injured reserve. This is quite the conundrum here...
Click to expand...
They would have to pay him on IR.

Since he was an early pick (3rd pick in the 2nd) his salary was not trivial.
 
At the risk of veering off into a Jaylon thread, I would guess the medicals opinions we're about equally distributed between never play again, never be the same if he did play and might be able to return to his former self.

Regardless, unless there is some other underlying issue, the Seahawks must be pretty confident in their medical staff to cut a high draft pick.
 
Not sure why we couldn't sign him to a minimum contract with incentives and with a medical waiver (i.e., he wont sue the team or league if permanent damage from playing)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Staff online

Members online

... and 101 more.
Total: 4,820 (members: 201, guests: 4,619)
Robots: 1,271

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
474,003
Messages
14,505,648
Members
24,207
Latest member
TomGiantsfan
Back
Top