Ha! I was 11 (almost) when Meredith retired. I was 20 when Roger hung it up and both days were dark for me as both guys could have kept playing. Dandy Don was only 31 when he retired after the debacle against the Browns in the 1968 playoffs.
I was hoping that Staubach would take over after Don retired but he was just coming out of his naval stint at the start of the 1969 season and hadn't practiced with the team as much as Morton had and Landry felt Craig was the readier of the two. Bad move IMO as it set us back a few years until Roger finally took over.
I believe that if Roger had come in sometime in that 1969 season we would have beaten the Browns in the playoffs and won the SB over the Chiefs (although KC had a great team that year). We also would have beaten the Colts in the 1970 SB if Roger had been the QB. Morton was a great guy but he had a tendency to throw high when he was pressured which resulted in a number of big plays that went the other way in that SB. If Meredith had kept playing another couple of years I believe we would have won in 69 & 70. He was a great QB who got beat up playing on some pretty poor teams.
I had high hopes in 1980 when Danny White stepped in and he really was an excellent QB but he wasn't Roger Staubach. Had Roger kept playing another 3 years, I am convinced that we would have won another couple of SBs.
Most of you are just kids who missed some of the greatest players to ever wear the