peplaw06;3302587 said:
How can you possibly pin wins or losses on a coach who isn't COACHING??? It's a no-brainer. He didn't get credit for the Gaudet wins either. If Duke had gone on to win the NCAA title that year, you wouldn't want that counted as a title for Coach K.
If Duke had gone on to win that year, it's a given that the year would not have been wiped out either.
This year is on Roy, though much of the early part of the year, Roy Williams was not with the team and it showed. That's no excuse, just a fact of the matter.
During Smith's years, there were a significant amount of years where the field was only 32 and many years where the field was as small as 22-25 teams. While Mike Krzyzewski has been head coach at Duke, the majority of time (80-82 only 48 teams) the field has been 64-65 teams. Point being, Krzyzewski might pass Smith but there were many many years where it was much more difficult to make the tourney then it is now.