No, MY logic dictates that you saw AR being an all time great QB over the course of almost two decades. Any metric that indicates he wasn't, is obviously flawed and should rightfully be ignored.
Your example is about team results rather than heads up talent comparison.
Also, I only find two head to head matchups. "Aaron Rodgers and Jimmy Garoppolo have faced each other just once in the NFL playoffs, and it was a memorable matchup that ended with a dramatic win for the San Francisco 49ers." The regular season game was won by GB. So 1-1 seems to be their heads-up record.