Miles Austin the best NFC East WR?

[Bob Sacamano]

we haven't visited this discussion in awhile

I remember all the worry-warts about the receiving corp heading into the season, and the comparisons between our group and the WR groups from the other division teams

I think it's safe to say that All Smiles is the best WR in the NFC East

 

[BigDinAZ]

I agree...

Although, the G-Girls seem to have luck on their side!

 

[SharutoX]

we haven't visited this discussion in awhile

I remember all the worry-warts about the receiving corp heading into the season, and the comparisons between our group and the WR groups from the other division teams

I think it's safe to say that All Smiles is the best WR in the NFC East

As much as i like Austin right now, I would take Desean Jackson over him for right now

 

[Boyzmamacita]

Interesting topic. I think you're right. Miles has convinced me at this point. We need him to keep it up. Maybe we should wear the throwbacks from here on out. Miles sure does ball with the stars on his shoulders.

 

[ajk23az]

Ranks of NFCE #1 WRs

1. Miles Austin
2. Steve Smith
3. DeSean Jackson
4. Santana Moss

 

[5Stars]

Interesting topic. I think you're right. Miles has convinced me at this point. We need him to keep it up. Maybe we should wear the throwbacks from here on out. Miles sure does ball with the stars on his shoulders.

The player is good! Lot's of miles on that dude.

:starspin

 

[Zman5]

Ranks of NFCE #1 WRs

1. Miles Austin
2. Steve Smith
3. DeSean Jackson
4. Santana Moss

That looks about right currently.

 

[jobberone]

I'd still pick Jackson and maybe Smith. Moss may be better. We don't have enough data yet. But it says a lot that he is being considered as a top East WR. Some called him a bust earlier this year.

 

[Rampage]

As much as i like Austin right now, I would take Desean Jackson over him for right now

if he doesn't beat you deep he doesn't beat you

 

[RCowboyFan]

Not sure he that much better than Desean Jackson yet. But he was impressive against arguablly the Best CB in NFL. Probably only Shutdown CB, if any, or at least close to one in NFL.

For now, I think Jackson and HIm are tied for first and maybe Steve smith proably a Second.

 

[ajk23az]

if he doesn't beat you deep he doesn't beat you

 

[ajk23az]

Not sure he that much better than Desean Jackson yet. But he was impressive against arguablly the Best CB in NFL. Probably only Shutdown CB, if any, or at least close to one in NFL.

For now, I think Jackson and HIm are tied for first and maybe Steve smith proably a Second.

Darelle Revis jumps up and down waving his hands!!

 

[5Stars]

I'd still pick Jackson and maybe Smith. Moss may be better. We don't have enough data yet. But it says a lot that he is being considered as a top East WR. Some called him a bust earlier this year.

Would you stop using all those huge words.

 

[RCowboyFan]

I'd still pick Jackson and maybe Smith. Moss may be better. We don't have enough data yet. But it says a lot that he is being considered as a top East WR. Some called him a bust earlier this year.

Smith is not dominating enough, or not a guy who scares a DB. He is a good Wr. Desean is a difference maker and so is Austin right now. Defense has to fear Desean or Austin taking it to the house any time. Smith is not that and wont ever be that IMO. He just doesn't have that elite speed to be one.

Only guy on Giants team I see in future who can do that is Mario Manningham right now.

 

[ThreeSportStar80]

Miles Austin put on a show today... He caught balls on their best CB so for those who think he didn't go look at the film.

 

[RCowboyFan]

Darelle Revis jumps up and down waving his hands!!

Yep, he might be the other guy. Probably 1A and 1B. Namdi has done it for longer time though.

 

[JBell]

Yep, he might be the other guy. Probably 1A and 1B. Namdi has done it for longer time though.

Charles Woodson would like a word with you.

 

[ajk23az]

Charles Woodson would like a word with you.

While he is arguably the DPOY right now, he is not a pure man to man cover guy. He stays on his one side of the ball.

I've seen Nnamdi move to both sides covering #1 WRs before but he didnt do that today. At least not that I saw. I know for a fact Revis goes to both sides, he has shut down Randy Moss twice this year.

 

[JBell]

While he is arguably the DPOY right now, he is not a pure man to man cover guy.

Um...

that's like saying Demarcus Ware is more of a coverage linebacker.

All GB does is run man. And he's been doing it his entire career.

 

[Rampage]

Um...

that's like saying Demarcus Ware is more of a coverage linebacker.

correctomundo