Mingo vs Tolbert

[Coogiguy03]

Who are you taking???? This is what it appears may be the lock for wide out #3!! Tolbert was our leading WR for touchdowns last season, but I think Mingo has done some good things so far in practice, hopefully that can be transferred to the games!! Please give your thoughts

 

[DallasEast]

Production in practice does not count. Preseason games will be a better indicator of how either player may lock down the #3 position for themselves.

 

[Coogiguy03]

Production in practice does not count. Preseason games will be a better indicator of how either player may lock down the #3 position for themselves.

Just wanted to see if anyone felt that because he had the season he had that he may have the upper hand???


Agree, Milton and grier better sling that ball so we can see what they got!!!!

 

[JayFord]

Tolbert and it’s not even close

7 TDS and 610 yards last season in a terrible season shows more than enough promise to be the 3rd option at receiver

 

[thunderpimp91]

Rooting for Mingo because he is the higher potential player. If Mingo doesn’t step up I honestly wouldn’t rule out a guy down the depth chart like a flournoy getting some of those snaps.

 

[Coogiguy03]

Tolbert and it’s not even close

7 TDS and 610 yards last season in a terrible season shows more than enough promise to be the 3rd option at receiver

Yes he did that before but is he capable of getting even more?

 

[thunderpimp91]

Tolbert and it’s not even close

7 TDS and 610 yards last season in a terrible season shows more than enough promise to be the 3rd option at receiver

Give almost any JAG receiver as many snaps as Tolbert got and they’ll give you 600 yards. In context his counting stats were just OK.

 

[JayFord]

Yes he did that before but is he capable of getting even more?

With Lamb and Pickens his numbers may go down to 500 yards and 5 touchdowns while having a greater impact on third down and red zone efficiency picking up chain movers

If lamb goes for 1300 and Pickens goes for 1100 it’s fine if Tolbert on paper looks worse but is more effective in game with most of his catches having impact kinda like Noah Brown and TY Hilton

 

[Teague31]

Mingo has more raw talent. Remains to be seen if that shows up consistently

 

[Coogiguy03]

With Lamb and Pickens his numbers may go down to 500 yards and 5 touchdowns while having a greater impact on third down and red zone efficiency picking up chain movers

If lamb goes for 1300 and Pickens goes for 1100 it’s fine if Tolbert on paper looks worse but is more effective in game with most of his catches having impact kinda like Noah Brown and TY Hilton

anything is possible

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Who are you taking???? This is what it appears may be the lock for wide out #3!! Tolbert was our leading WR for touchdowns last season, but I think Mingo has done some good things so far in practice, hopefully that can be transferred to the games!! Please give your thoughts

Tolbert has produced more. Mingo still doesn't have a TD in NFL and was 6th on panthers team. 5 other WRs surpassed him. He did zero here last year. Stupid stupid stupid trade

 

[Coogiguy03]

Tolbert has produced more. Mingo still doesn't have a TD in NFL and was 6th on panthers team. 5 other WRs surpassed him. He did zero here last year. Stupid stupid stupid trade

Sometimes players just need a change of scenery, or he may be just what he's been in Car

 

[slick325]

I'll go with Tolbert. I think he can make a really good WR3. He just wasn't ready to be WR2 last season. He should prosper against 3rd and 4th CBs.

But, as @thunderpimp91 said, I am also rooting for Mingo since he has a higher ceiling. Dallas needs them both to take big strides this season so the offense can really be super explosive. (That and a solid running game).

 

[Coogiguy03]

I'll go with Tolbert. I think he can make a really good WR3. He just wasn't ready to be WR2 last season. He should prosper against 3rd and 4th CBs.

But, as @thunderpimp91 said, I am also rooting for Mingo since he has a higher ceiling. Dallas needs them both to take big strides this season so the offense can really be super explosive. (That and a solid running game).

Good points, gosh forbid that lamb or pickens goes out and he's going against #1 and 2 CB's then what?

 

[charron]

I'd have to go with Tolbert based on who has produced more here.

 

[Ironicalicon]

Who are you taking???? This is what it appears may be the lock for wide out #3!! Tolbert was our leading WR for touchdowns last season, but I think Mingo has done some good things so far in practice, hopefully that can be transferred to the games!! Please give your thoughts

We have a third invested in one player and a 4th invested in the other but Mingo is a little younger and probably the better athlete so give me Mingo. However, he is probably the longshot of the two. All in all, I don't care.

Actually, I'd rather it be Flournoy as he is cheaper and under contract longer.

 

[CalPolyTechnique]

Give almost any JAG receiver as many snaps as Tolbert got and they’ll give you 600 yards. In context his counting stats were just OK.

You're not factoring in playing with Cooper Rush.

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

Sometimes players just need a change of scenery, or he may be just what he's been in Car

right now its tolbert.
Mingo has to earn his keep. but I think at the end of the day, Cowboys will let tolbert walk and keep mingo for another year.

 

[Coogiguy03]

right now its tolbert.
Mingo has to earn his keep. but I think at the end of the day, Cowboys will let tolbert walk and keep mingo for another year.

That would be wild!!!

 

[CowboysFaninHouston]

That would be wild!!!

well, let me clarify. both are here this year. tolbert is FA next year. that's when we let him walk and keep mingo as the 3rd WR. not sure if I was clear on that.