Most Overrated Prospect

[RS12]

No brainers Burrow. Tight window throws not his strong suit which is a problem. Cincinnati will be a bigger problem.

 

[timb2]

Lol, I find it shocking how many people think Tua is overrated.

Another Shrimp and it is always the same argument from the crowd of little people. "How about Drew Brees & Russell Wilson"? Hey Lilaputians, how about all the Tall QBs that have done well? Roger Staubauch,Jim Kelly,John Elway,Tom Brady,Peyton Manning,Doug Williams,Terry Bradshaw,Dan Marino,Dan Fouts,Cam Newton,Joe Montana,Troy Aikman,etc...???? I can name more than the 5 midget QBs they always respond with Brees,Tarkington,Flutie,Wilson,and now Murray that have bombed. Todd Santos,Ty Detmer,Tom Clements, Colt Brennan,Timmy Chang,Koy Detmer,,Aaron Murray,Chase McDaniel,Kevin Sweeney,Kellen Moore,Case Keenum,Colt McCoy,etc.......Percentage is on my side Tua flops

 

[tm1119]

Another Shrimp and it is always the same argument from the crowd of little people. "How about Drew Brees & Russell Wilson"? Hey Lilaputians, how about all the Tall QBs that have done well? Roger Staubauch,Jim Kelly,John Elway,Tom Brady,Peyton Manning,Doug Williams,Terry Bradshaw,Dan Marino,Dan Fouts,Cam Newton,Joe Montana,Troy Aikman,etc...???? I can name more than the 5 midget QBs they always respond with Brees,Tarkington,Flutie,Wilson,and now Murray that have bombed. Todd Santos,Ty Detmer,Tom Clements, Colt Brennan,Timmy Chang,Koy Detmer,,Aaron Murray,Chase McDaniel,Kevin Sweeney,Kellen Moore,Case Keenum,Colt McCoy,etc.......Percentage is on my side Tua flops

Lol...what are you trying to do with that list? That’s a comically bad argument. You just compared a bunch of late round draft picks that NO ONE ever expected to be franchise QB’s to a guy who is a lock to be a top 10 pick.

 

[Hardline]

chase Young. Its very hard to translate to the pro level from DE/dt. The speed of the game and such. The talent level he will face each week. I suspect he will struggle all year.

He went ten consecutive quarters last season sackless.

 

[Hardline]

Ruggs

More underrated than overrated.
He's going to kill it in the NFL.

 

[CalPolyTechnique]

He went ten consecutive quarters last season sackless.

After going nine (9) straight games with a sack (16.5 sacks in nine games).

Joey Bosa had just 5 sacks in 12 games his last season.

 

[reddyuta]

Justin Herbert-I really dont see it in him,some team will draft him in the top 10 and they will be dissapointed.

 

[beware_d-ware]

He went ten consecutive quarters last season sackless.

Wisconsin is one of those games where he went sackless. You want to know why?

 

[timb2]

Lol...what are you trying to do with that list? That’s a comically bad argument. You just compared a bunch of late round draft picks that NO ONE ever expected to be franchise QB’s to a guy who is a lock to be a top 10 pick.

They dropped because they were small. How did Cade McNown do? 1st round flop....How about Johnny Manziel????

 

[fivetwos]

Delpit is another easy one.

Liability as a tackler, small framed guy. He made a a lot of plays at the LOS but that’s a role I don’t see him playing as a pro.

Brugler has him as a 2nd round prospect and that’s where I have him to.

Agreed fully. Both top ranked safeties in fact.

Very much hoping we address this in FA.

 

[cnuball21]

More underrated than overrated.
He's going to kill it in the NFL.

I think he’ll be a very solid compliment WR to a good #1 but will not warrant how high he goes.

The hit rate on smaller speed WRs is also fairly low and those guys seem to struggle with injuries.

 

[cnuball21]

Wisconsin is one of those games where he went sackless. You want to know why?

The idea of Chase Young being overrated completely blows my mind.

Hes one of the best pass rush prospects if the last decade and believe the highest PFF grade of all time at the position.

 

[cowboyec]

Burrow.

 

[Carson]

The idea of Chase Young being overrated completely blows my mind.

Hes one of the best pass rush prospects if the last decade and believe the highest PFF grade of all time at the position.

Im not saying he’s overrated because the kid is going to be a stud.

I just don’t think he’s the second coming of LT or a Reggie White

 

[cnuball21]

Im not saying he’s overrated because the kid is going to be a stud.

I just don’t think he’s the second coming of LT or a Reggie White

Maybe not, but if he stays healthy I think he's a multi time All Pro caliber talent.

 

[Illinoiscowboy]

Xavier McKinney


He’s a nice player that plays a position that you can get by with a player like Jeff Heath and it not effect the outcomes of a game negatively.

McKinney is a 2nd round player that people have overrated and have him going in round 1.

McKinney got ran over near the goal line by a Lsu rb last year, that's the highlight of him that stays in my mind

 

[Cowboyny]

Ruggs.

Outside of Hill, many speed demons have failed on the next level. Hell, we have one former high 1st rd pick on the roster-Tavon Austin.

 

[CATCH17]

Burrow.

Here is the problem with thinking Burrow won’t be good..

He’s just too athletic.. The guy can flat out run and buy time in the pocket. So whatever shortcomings he could potentially have like arm strength or small hands is gonna be overcome by him having Aaron Rodgers (maybe better) athleticism.

 

[cnuball21]

Ruggs.

Outside of Hill, many speed demons have failed on the next level. Hell, we have one former high 1st rd pick on the roster-Tavon Austin.

100%. I think he’s a good WR but the history of the league tells us that kind of player isn’t worth a 1st round pick.

 

[cowboyec]

Here is the problem with thinking Burrow won’t be good..

He’s just too athletic.. The guy can flat out run and buy time in the pocket. So whatever shortcomings he could potentially have like arm strength or small hands is gonna be overcome by him having Aaron Rodgers (maybe better) athleticism.

its probably more "over-hyped" than over-rated.
i think he'll be a good pro....but some media folks go beyond that.
i think he'll be good....not great.
i still think Tua is the best QB in the class.