My thoughts on the draft so far

Galian Beast

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,735
Reaction score
7,457
The first thing that comes to mind is themes. Thematically there is a clear sign of what the team is doing.

Let's first start with what message the team put out there early in the offseason, which was that the draft would be organized around the idea that Romo will be playing for the next 4-5 years, whether that turns out to be the case or not, that is how the organization is moving forward.

So that tells me the draft has to continue to be Romo friendly, which means maximizing the window he has available. So the theme is to help the team and help the team the most within this 4-5 year window.

What player in the draft did many of us and many in the media suggest would help us the most in 2016? Hands down that player was Ezekiel Elliott. He is one of the most well rounded running backs to come into the NFL. His production shouldn't be overlooked either. He might not be as dynamic a player as say Peterson or Gurley, but he was actually more productive than both of them. He's also younger than Adrian Peterson was coming into the league. We may not have even seen this kids ceiling yet. If he is anywhere close to as productive as Peterson behind this offensive line with the outside talent we have at receiver, we're going to have an excellent offense for the next 5 years. This helps our defense tremendously, especially in those first 4 games of the season.

Jaylon Smith comes next, and I think part of the reason you can draft a Jaylon Smith is because you drafted Ezekiel Elliott. The team was obviously more comfortable drafting Smith with his medical issues than they were Spence with his character issues, despite the team needed help with pass rush. It should be noted that in 2014 our best pass rusher was George Selvie. Gregory and Lawrence whether we can rely on them or not are significantly better than Selvie. Smith gives you the ability to get an elite talent even if it isn't right away. His contribution to the Romo window should be significant if he is that top 5 or top 10 draft caliber player for you. That's how you give a major shot towards increasing your defensive capabilities. My guess is if he is healthy McClain is gone next year.

There are some questions about that too however. Most had him pegged as more of an outside linebacker rather than a middle linebacker. So, it was very strange to hear them say they saw him as in inside guy. It'll be interesting to see if that is what really happens. It is also interesting that they had him above Myles Jack, so it would be interesting to see how they both progress medically and talent wise on the field.

I'd still like to see McClain put it all together and have Lee - McClain - Smith

If you compare our secondary to 2014, we're better now than we were then.
If you compare our linebackers to 2014, we're much better now than we were then, especially if Smith can play at any point this year or next year (Lee was out for the season).
If you compare our defensive line to 2014, I'd argue we're also better than we were then even with the suspensions, but we're significantly better with the return of Lawrence and Gregory.

So I think we've established that we're better on defense, perhaps significantly better on defense than 2014.

What about on offense?

That brings us back to Elliott who is much better than DeMarco Murray, has much better vision than DeMarco Murray and more talent as well. We also have McFadden and Morris who are both better than Randle backing him up. The talent at RB is insane at the moment compared to what we had in 2014.

I think we're better at WR simply because we have essentially the same group, but they're all more experienced.

At tight end we're similar, but this might be the only spot where we're worse, but not demonstrably worse.

The offensive line should be even better in 2016 than it was in 2014 since we've added Collins who is now entering his second year pro. A huge upgrade over Leary. The question is what happens at right tackle.

I would have liked to see them bring in a QB like Hoyer, McCoy, or Moore. Surprised they haven't paid more attention to the backup spot, though I'm pleased they didn't use a pick on it. Wouldn't be furious if they picked someone up in the 4th round though.
 

JBell

That's still my Quarterback
Messages
5,699
Reaction score
6,840
I love what they did on Day 2. They addressed the team's biggest need with both picks.

I'm really intrigued by Jaylon Smith as an edge rusher, and Maliek Collins gives us another guy besides Crawford who create some pass rush from the interior.
 

percyhoward

Research Tool
Messages
17,062
Reaction score
21,861
I don't think Elliott was a complete waste of a pick, since he was the best player on our board and we needed an upgrade at the RB position. I do think we could have made better use of the four picks though, by drafting defense in the first three rounds and RB in the fourth. There's no reason to believe Murray was clearly a better player in 2014 than Dixon, Booker, Perkins, etc. would be behind this line in 2016. Irrespective of the value of RB in general, the quality of our offensive line makes the RB position the one where we least needed an elite player. But all that assumes Romo has a couple of good years left. I don't think the team is assuming that at all.

The Smith selection seemed to run contrary to "win now," but if they think Romo's days are really numbered, then the first two picks make a whole lot more sense. Whichever QB succeeds Romo won't be as good as Romo, certainly not right away. We got the best RB, and we wanted Lynch. It seems the idea was to get better at the skill positions ASAP without going all out for one of the top two QB. Higgins in the 4th would make more sense than ever now. Drafting a franchise QB next year is obviously a must, and it's obviously going to cost us.

In explaining the team's selection of Elliott, Jerry mentioned how Garrett had told him how good it felt as a backup QB to have Emmitt to dump off to. The Jones' are approaching things like the next play could be Romo's last.
 

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,835
Reaction score
103,565
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I'm not seeing some grand 'Master Plan' like some people are trying to convince me of, but rather inconsistancy across the board.

From the end of the season, we've gone from needing to address backup quarterback to not needing to. Suddenly, they're trying to polish up Kellen Moore because they didn't get anyone else.

We had a capped salary for running back, so we weren't going over it for Murray or Lamar Miller. But then, that goes out the window for Elliott. Even after the team had already acquired Alfred Morris.

And most recently, the team officially closes the door on Greg Hardy, after two days where they don't draft a defensive end, following news of both projected starters being suspended for the first month of the season.

And the draft so far has gone from 'biggest impact in 2016' (Elliott) to no impact in 2016 (Smith).

I don't want to hear about any 'plan' when it's obvious they don't have one.
 

1972COWBOY

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
1,901
There is a possibility Jaylon would have fallen to the 3rd. We still have Kellen Moore who has a nice throw. I know his debut was rocky but the whole team was rocky at that point. If you look at Troy's stats for his first year they were rocky too. I would like to give Moore another try under better conditions. Moore was pressured to not only perform but turn the team around making him throw passes he would have probably held if things were better.

We do need a 3rd quarterback though just in case Moore doesn't pan out.
 

Howboutdemcowboys31

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,093
Reaction score
9,457
I'm not seeing some grand 'Master Plan' like some people are trying to convince me of, but rather inconsistancy across the board.

From the end of the season, we've gone from needing to address backup quarterback to not needing to. Suddenly, they're trying to polish up Kellen Moore because they didn't get anyone else.

We had a capped salary for running back, so we weren't going over it for Murray or Lamar Miller. But then, that goes out the window for Elliott. Even after the team had already acquired Alfred Morris.

And most recently, the team officially closes the door on Greg Hardy, after two days where they don't draft a defensive end, following news of both projected starters being suspended for the first month of the season.

And the draft so far has gone from 'biggest impact in 2016' (Elliott) to no impact in 2016 (Smith).

I don't want to hear about any 'plan' when it's obvious they don't have one.

I would've liked Murray or Lamar, but Zeke is the superior player and most importantly younger then both
 

Section446

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,941
Reaction score
11,619
I don't think Elliott was a complete waste of a pick, since he was the best player on our board and we needed an upgrade at the RB position. I do think we could have made better use of the four picks though, by drafting defense in the first three rounds and RB in the fourth. There's no reason to believe Murray was clearly a better player in 2014 than Dixon, Booker, Perkins, etc. would be behind this line in 2016. Irrespective of the value of RB in general, the quality of our offensive line makes the RB position the one where we least needed an elite player. But all that assumes Romo has a couple of good years left. I don't think the team is assuming that at all.

The Smith selection seemed to run contrary to "win now," but if they think Romo's days are really numbered, then the first two picks make a whole lot more sense. Whichever QB succeeds Romo won't be as good as Romo, certainly not right away. We got the best RB, and we wanted Lynch. It seems the idea was to get better at the skill positions ASAP without going all out for one of the top two QB. Higgins in the 4th would make more sense than ever now. Drafting a franchise QB next year is obviously a must, and it's obviously going to cost us.

In explaining the team's selection of Elliott, Jerry mentioned how Garrett had told him how good it felt as a backup QB to have Emmitt to dump off to. The Jones' are approaching things like the next play could be Romo's last.

We've known for some time that Romo's days are numbered, and so do they. I don't think we need to categorize their draft strategy, they're simply following their board, and not reaching for need, and it's virtually impossible to blame them for it.
 

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,796
Reaction score
16,662
I'm not seeing some grand 'Master Plan' like some people are trying to convince me of, but rather inconsistancy across the board.

From the end of the season, we've gone from needing to address backup quarterback to not needing to. Suddenly, they're trying to polish up Kellen Moore because they didn't get anyone else.

We had a capped salary for running back, so we weren't going over it for Murray or Lamar Miller. But then, that goes out the window for Elliott. Even after the team had already acquired Alfred Morris.

And most recently, the team officially closes the door on Greg Hardy, after two days where they don't draft a defensive end, following news of both projected starters being suspended for the first month of the season.

And the draft so far has gone from 'biggest impact in 2016' (Elliott) to no impact in 2016 (Smith).

Well said lol there does seem to be no real plan,

I liked getting elliot, but a #2 on jalyn was odd, and a gamble, then a DT not a DE.
I found that odd as we got cedric in FA , and just gave crawford the big contract.
He is a big DT, so he may be useful in run situations,

I also found the GH deal odd, they waited till after day 1 and 2 to announce it and did not get
a de lol.
I think that could be jg and some of the other coaches did not want him back, not anything else.

I don't want to hear about any 'plan' when it's obvious they don't have one.
 

JohnsKey19

Well-Known Member
Messages
19,694
Reaction score
18,723
I'm ok with the offseason. My only real issue is they are short one starting caliber DE and I think they should've done more in FA to address.

They're putting a lot of pressure on Marinelli to mix-and-match and get by with smoke and mirrors at DE until Lawrence returns.
 

superonyx

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,478
Reaction score
15,836
I'm not seeing some grand 'Master Plan' like some people are trying to convince me of, but rather inconsistancy across the board.

From the end of the season, we've gone from needing to address backup quarterback to not needing to. Suddenly, they're trying to polish up Kellen Moore because they didn't get anyone else.

We had a capped salary for running back, so we weren't going over it for Murray or Lamar Miller. But then, that goes out the window for Elliott. Even after the team had already acquired Alfred Morris.

And most recently, the team officially closes the door on Greg Hardy, after two days where they don't draft a defensive end, following news of both projected starters being suspended for the first month of the season.

And the draft so far has gone from 'biggest impact in 2016' (Elliott) to no impact in 2016 (Smith).

I don't want to hear about any 'plan' when it's obvious they don't have one.

It seems rather obvious that you failed to understand the teams position on running back salary. Is it such a reach to believe that maybe, just maybe the team feels Zeke Elliott is more valuable and less risky than paying Lamar Miller or Demarco Murray...I wanted both Murray and Miller but even I can understand how a 20 year old Elliott is more valuable than 27 year old Murray who was injured every year of his career or Lamar Miller who is less physical in style and for some reason was never viewed by the Dolphins as a guy who could carry a heavy load.

Looking at how they passed on a guy like Spence and closed the door on Hardy shows the team has put extra emphasis on character. Also they don't want to carry a guy and his issues for 4 years to attempt to fix a 4 week problem.

No team is 100% void of weakness. It's the nature of the NFL. But fans focus on any weakness that exist in the roster and freak out over them.
 

Section446

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,941
Reaction score
11,619
I'm ok with the offseason. My only real issue is they are short one starting caliber DE and I think they should've done more in FA to address.

They're putting a lot of pressure on Marinelli to mix-and-match and get by with smoke and mirrors at DE until Lawrence returns.
Sounds like Crawford is going to be the guy.
 

cowboyblue22

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,031
Reaction score
8,707
smith wasn't going to the third round the pats were going to draft him in the second.
 

percyhoward

Research Tool
Messages
17,062
Reaction score
21,861
.And the draft so far has gone from 'biggest impact in 2016' (Elliott) to no impact in 2016 (Smith).

I don't want to hear about any 'plan' when it's obvious they don't have one.
If there is a plan, it isn't "win now with Romo."

If you want to win now with Romo, you draft defenders who can play now, and take one of these RB in the 4th. Elliott and Smith make more sense if you're thinking about life after Romo.
 

Verdict

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,230
Reaction score
20,501
Interesting draft so far. The interesting thing that this draft class has, some of which hasn't hasn't always been the case:

1. Name recognition! EE and Smith are both guys you have heard about for quite some time. That should be good news that these players have been viewed as the **** for quite some time, and not just underwear award winners. You can exclude pick 3 from this list so far, because he isn't a household name, which tends to happen the farther you fall in the draft.

2. So far, all 3 come from major football schools in power conferences. I think it bodes well that we are adding great players off of the best teams from the best programs in the country.

3. I think the first two picks have the potential to be ALL PROS which is outstanding.

4. The third round pick, I'm not nearly as excited about, but after the Cowboys have shown that they know a lot more than the public seems to give them credit for, I am willing to wait and see on this pick. I can't say I love this pick, but I am willing to push the pause button and wait and see. What I do like about this pick is that DT was supposed to be the deepest part of this draft, and we got one of this deep class at the top of the 3rd round. purportedly before the talent ran out. Hopefully this pick does what he was drafted to do.
 
Top