joseephuss;2133067 said:
Is a 6th rounder worth something or not? You say you would rather not gamble on a UDFA like Romo again. You then say that a 6th rounder is not worth much, but worth gambling with. Just seems contradictory.
If you're willing to guarantee me the 6th rounder will turn out like Romo? Sure.
But the fact is that Romo is a once in a lifetime exception, not the rule.
joseephus said:
Dallas needed to draft O-line in 2004 when they chose both Rogers and Peterman. They picked poorly, but at that time they already had a young, talented, early round WR on the roster in Antonio Bryant. Counting on him was a bad choice, but he is what you say you are looking for.
Bryant is another example of the Cowboys acquiring a receiver with 'issues'. Bryant was a first round talent with an attitude problem. That's why he was available to Dallas.
joseephus said:
They also had Terry Glenn who did not have a degenerative knee condition at the time and Keyshawn Johnson. They picked up Crayton in the 7th round and Terrence Copper. Seems to me that they did do exactly what you were talking about. They tried to address the WR position and unfortunately only Crayton worked out of those choices from that year.
Glenn's knee condition had been known about for two years. And the ages of both Glenn and Owens weren't secret either. How'd they 'get' Copper? I'm talking about a draft investment, not strictly late rounders and free agents.
joseephus said:
I didn't like the Fasano pick in 2006. In that draft there were 5 receivers drafted after Fasano in the 3rd round that Dallas could have picked. Travis Wilson, Derek Hagan, Brandon Williams, Maurice Stoval and Willie Reid were all taken in the 3rd round. I don't see any of them solving Dallas wide receiver issues. Dallas would have been better off picking up someone at another position rather than drafting Fasano, but WR was not a good pick in that second round spot. It would have taken a trade and maybe they did try to trade up, but had no takers. You just never know.
While we're playing revisionist history, the Cowboys also could have gotten Greg Jennings in round 2 had they stayed put. (probably forgot about the trade huh?)
Or how about Santonio Holmes instead of Carpenter in Round 1?
That looks smarter after the fact too.