I don't think it's ridiculous and it's not being haters, its being obviously honest. Show me all the teams that had that kind of talent literally the "
all in" because not many teams do it so don't say it's been done & other quarterbacks have failed, because I haven't seen that too often.. it's usually the other way around.. It might be the case that that team may have fell short, but it might also have been because of injuries prior to the game or in the game I mean let's keep some perspective here....
We've seen throughout history; guys like Nick Fole, Trent Dilfer, and Brad Johnson just to name a few. I mean I'll even put Jim McMahon in there just simple bus drivers, don't screw it up but if you do, we'll have your back as our defense and our trench work total team coaching staffs have been great and you don't have to be perfect at quarterback as a matter of fact you don't even need a great quarterback... Think about some of the spare quarterbacks that had great defenses that didn't make the Super Bowl or maybe they did make the Super Bowl but most of the championship games..
I can remember just off the top of my head Blake Bortals and Mark Sanchez were not that good and by the way neither was Danny White they were on super teams and yes they fell short, but there's a reason.. they looked at it as hey at least they made the championship game no no no no the defense is the special teams and the plays made by the players around them is why they got that far..
Dak and Romo have not, If you can't see why we're having this discussion that's the problem,
no one's dismissing Jalen hurts he did play very well in both Super Bowls he did fumble he did have an interception but their defense wasn't good enough in the 1st one the defense flat out shut down everyone in this last Super Bowl that's why they won the game he wasn't even necessarily needed in my opinion he probably could have ran with their backup and just handed the ball to Semicon Barkley play small ball and play defense and probably still won that game....
BTW To be fair I look at Troy Aikman and Roger Staubach the same way dude those teams were absolutely ridiculous and they would not have performed much better than Romo or DAC on these particular teams the last 1520 years they just wouldn't they would not have the success the success wasn't because of the quarterback alone yes they were talented... But if you look at the games if you look at they made mistakes in those games interceptions fumbles they were not perfect but they were not asked to be perfect so when I'm judging my own heroes for the Dallas Cowboys I can also judge Jalen hurts the same way and he's being overrated we're not saying Don't give him his flowers but don't act like this dude's better than Prescott he's not...
He just happens to be on a better team
This is why this narrative was created people talk about this because Jalen hurts had it easy, if he was with the Cowboys he wouldn't be doing squat, would he be as effective or similar to Prescott, Sure, that's why we know you put Prescott over there and they still win a Super Bowl..
that's the point there are very few teams that do this this is why Matthew Stafford was always looked at like Tony Romo a great player on a team that just wouldn't do enough and as soon as he gets over to the all in Rams he's the same player he didn't change led the league in interceptions had two interceptions in the Super Bowl they had his back the defense was that good and they won that game.
Nobody seems to mention the turnovers it doesn't matter that's why just like Jalen hurts he had an early interception they just snuffed it out it didn't matter that defense said I have your back the coaches said I have your back the running backs and all the receivers that I have your back don't worry about it and they went on to win..
Don't tell me that somehow you're dismissing how great that defense just executed and the game plans and the play calling to shut down Andy Reid's offense that is led by one of the best quarterbacks to ever play the game in Patrick Mahomes they literally said no matter what you're not going to have to play perfectly or score a lot of points to win this game and they went out on all three phases in coaching and did that that is why you're going to hear that Jalen hurts should not be given that kind of credit because we haven't seen him too often without this type of team around him because when he's been like that his rookie year or second year he's looked very average or normal whatever you want to call it...