Prime Randy Moss vs Megatron

[JBS]

What asterisks are by Calvin Johnson's records? Truth is, as great as Moss was, his best season by far was with Brady in 2007 at an age Johnson hasn't even gotten to yet

None. But I'm not making excuses. 1700 yards as a rookie. Let's not make excuses for years played and blah blah blah

 

[joseephuss]

None. But I'm not making excuses. 1700 yards as a rookie. Let's not make excuses for years played and blah blah blah

Who had 1700 yards as a rookie? Moss had 1313 yards his rookie season. Are you talking about someone else?

 

[khiladi]

Calvin Johnson
1 playoff game
12 receptions
211 yards
2 TDs

Randy Moss
15 playoff games
54 receptions
977 yards
10 TDs

Terrell Owens
12 playoff games
54 receptions
751 yards
5 TDs

Michael Irvin
16 games
87 receptions
1315 yards
8 TDs

I'm astonished Kevin Ogletree ain't up there...

 

[Teren_Kanan]

Top 2 highest scoring offenses of all time have Randy Moss in common.

 

[khiladi]

Calvin Johnson
1 playoff game
12 receptions
211 yards
2 TDs

Randy Moss
15 playoff games
54 receptions
977 yards
10 TDs

Terrell Owens
12 playoff games
54 receptions
751 yards
5 TDs

Michael Irvin
16 games
87 receptions
1315 yards
8 TDs

Michael Irvin equals winner... And Emmitt always got the TDs...

 

[khiladi]

There is no asterisk by the 23 TDs Randy Moss caught in 2007. There should be an asterisk by the 22 TDs Jerry Rice caught in 1987 because the strike/lockout caused Rice to miss 4 games. I imagine he would have caught a few more TDs that year had he been able to play in those games.

damn...

 

[Doomsday]

Top 2 highest scoring offenses of all time have Randy Moss in common.

How many Super Bowls did those 2 teams win?

 

[Phoenix]

I'm astonished Kevin Ogletree ain't up there...

You mean Andre Holmes?

I'd go Moss over Megatron. But it is incredibly close.