Sure I’ll argue that: I didn’t put Watson in tier 1. That was never the argument. Again you’re attempting to stereotype and just throw me into a group of other people here claiming other things when my list is clearly presented with Watson missing from the top tier.
being accused of sexual assault is a terrible thing, but it doesn’t affect his ability to throw a football. Dak does a lot of commercials, is great at selling products, and has a pristine reputation. Do you believe that makes him better at player quarterback…? Then why would the Deshaun thing have any impact on his QBing?
If a Qb breaks his leg, misses a season, is he now worse at playing QB? No, especially if the leg fills heals. Now What if that scenario happened but the leg never breaks and he’s physically fine? How does that suddenly make him a worse QB?
They are not the same caliber because one has proven to be more talented than the other. And now Again you’re talking about W/L record against winning teams or “getting fat” against losing teams, when you yourself don’t believe in it. Your only argument against Deshaun is one you directly dispute.
I never said his sexual assault cases has anything to do with throwing the football. What I SAID was he had to take a year off from football because of his sexual assault cases. I'm not going to sit here and assume that he's the same guy he was in 2020 when he went 4-12 but padded his stats. You know the thing y'all say Dak does?
Jesus.....there is NO ARGUMENT for Dak being better than Deshaun. I NEVER ONCE said that. What I said was they are the SAME CALIBER. You've yet to post nothing to suggest they aren't. You can go to your "padded stats" argument, you can go to your "W/L" argument, you can go to whatever you want....there is nothing here to suggest Deshaun Watson is a tier better than Dak Prescott other than your preference.
If a Qb breaks his leg, misses a season, is he now worse at playing QB? No, especially if the leg fills heals. Now What if that scenario happened but the leg never breaks and he’s physically fine? How does that suddenly make him a worse QB?
Because taking a year off from football hurts your play especially in the NFL. Dak's and Joe Burrow will be better quarterbacks this year than they were last season having a true offseason without worrying about injury. True or false?
Tier 3 is Pro Bowl Caliber: QB’s who will put up nice stats if the Oline is healthy and the skill positions are well-invested. QB’s who can reliably finish the season with winning records when everything is going right, will make an occasional pro bowl if a guy higher on the list is injured, Though will rarely if ever be considered for All-Pro. Also Not impossible to make a super bowl run of the team is loaded.
You literally described Deshaun Watson lol. Deshaun Watson is never going on a SB run unless his team is loaded lol. Same argument can be made for Russell Wilson,. Herbert and Stafford.
Truthfully, none of these quarterbacks are making a SB run without a team that's loaded lol.
This whole tier thing is just fodder created by the media and armchair GM's.
At the end of the day the best teams win. Eli Manning won 2 SB's. Never had the best team around him but they peaked at the right time and with the proper coaching. But for some strange reason, you guys are trying to convince me there's some imaginary "tier" of quarterback that's not defined by "wins" but defined by how far you can throw the football and how hard you can throw it. ITs ridiculous. We judge quarterbacks based on team result. Let's just call it what it is. Nobody gave Romo or Phillip Rivers the passes for their teams not being good enough.
