BAT
Mr. Fixit
- Messages
- 19,443
- Reaction score
- 15,607
This post says two different things at once.
The first bolded part was in reference to SUCCESS not talent (blue chip or otherwise).
This post says two different things at once.
Didnt like the player before the draft, didnt like the pick on draft day and still dont. Not even going into his off the field problems, the guy is weak. Will never be able to handle LTs.
First don't tell me what to do. And I haven't characterized you at all although you would be correct to assume I've called you out for your insensitivity and lack of knowledge about the subject matter. Without training you and everyone else is shooting from the hip. So I'm not being judgmental towards you. However, without proper training and knowledge, as I said before, you may want to temper your comments.
No I don't have access to his file. However, I have enough years of practice and training to be able to make a statement within a reasonable degree of medical certainty (a medical and legal statement to clarify my closely chosen words) that he has some mental problems and the overwhelmingly likely diagnoses at least includes some degree of depression with comorbid anxiety. I'd even be surprised if there aren't some further comorbid diagnoses and I'd be looking for ADD/ADHD and a personality disorder. I can't know for a fact without testing and lots of questions but I'd be right 90+% of the time in a patient with an addictive personality and an active addiction there is an element of depression and anxiety as well as sleep dysfunction. I don't really expect you to even understand this plain English as you don't have the background to filter it and you have become entrenched in a pissing contest with me rather than with the issues.
I've given you and the site very good information and you're welcome to embrace or reject it in toto or in parts as you wish. I have zero vested interest in changing your opinion about anything. I do take a small amount of exception with comments from lay people which tend to drive mental disorders into the shadows rather than into treatment. You don't treat patients and you've never been responsible for the care of another human being who committed suicide on your watch.
You have a nice evening and that will be my last comment in this thread. You're welcome to the last word.
He would be suspended for 10 games. Yes, I do realize everything regarding his circumstances.
You're using the word naive and it's naive to believe that the majority of these guys all have their marbles in check.
I'm not standing up for the guy or even giving him sympathy. I'm just stating the realities of the NFL and players don't just get written off because of "illness" or "addiction. Guess why? The majority of them have a variety of issues. The NFL is not going to just tell you that.
They get paid to smash one another around. You do realize that, don't you?
You sound like a guy who gets paid $6 million per year to coach and develop players.
All I hear out of you is words like naive and dumb.
So just write the guy off cause he's not a RKG (coach speak), when the rest of the league doesn't just "write" their guys off. But then to come up with a player model (RKG) in your words "coach speak" is just that.
Anyways, your right bud, cause that's all you want to hear.
I'm going to make it simple for you instead of going back and forth.
This is the NFL where players get paid to smash one another around. Half of them, star players included, have issues physically or mentally. It does not mean they are right or wrong, it means that is the reality of the business and it's core component that it sells. The players.
If you want to win, you have to understand that this is a huge variable and you better get some system/support in place to be able to work with these players you invested millions in. Just cutting them will not help you win as every team has a percentage of these challenges. The better you are at managing these challenges the higher your probability of being competitive is.
Boy does San Fran look so much better without Aldon Smith. How many Superbowls did we win with Charles Haley?
Accept the reality, you are going to have to deal with some of this on every team. Pot, assault, DUI's. Even underwear stealing. Many different types of cases. Let's get rid of Oscan, he had some molly in his system the other year.
You think Jason Witten grows off trees?
RKG has nothing to do with giving someone a shot. I think the term is dumb because it never gets followed here in Dallas. I would'nt follow it either if I was Jones. But Garrett talks as if we do follow it here and its just laughable he keeps doing it. Its almost like an inside joke on Garrett by the fan base.
As far as writing off Gregory, I am not advocating cutting him today. That would be writing him off. I am just trying to give you advice that at this point, dont get your hopes up. If I was a betting man I would say that the chances of him staying in Dallas long enough to actually develop into the pass rushing demon his talent might provide is getting less and less. Mentally for me, I am not counting on him at all. And I dont think the Cowboys are either. You cant run your ship counting on guys like that. Now you can hope all you want. Have at it.
RKG has nothing to do with giving someone a shot. I think the term is dumb because it never gets followed here in Dallas. I would'nt follow it either if I was Jones. But Garrett talks as if we do follow it here and its just laughable he keeps doing it. Its almost like an inside joke on Garrett by the fan base.
As far as writing off Gregory, I am not advocating cutting him today. That would be writing him off. I am just trying to give you advice that at this point, dont get your hopes up. If I was a betting man I would say that the chances of him staying in Dallas long enough to actually develop into the pass rushing demon his talent might provide is getting less and less. Mentally for me, I am not counting on him at all. And I dont think the Cowboys are either. You cant run your ship counting on guys like that. Now you can hope all you want. Have at it.
Not counting on him at all. Not writing him off. Just showcasing his talent that he is wasting.
There's not 1 NFL team that does not have a head case on the team. That simple.
Will Gregory implode? Highly likely. Already has twice.
All teams do and still need a support staff to stay competitive like I said. Good posts.
It never gets followed here in Dallas? The majority of draft picks they've brought in are team captains. RKG doesn't mean they won't gamble on guys getting their act together.
RKG has to do with players that are team first, want to develop and know how to stay out of trouble.
Examples: Jason Witten, Sean Lee
Anti RKG's: Ro McClain, Randy Gregory
Nobody is obligated to, but you didn't watch the video did you?
He's far from weak. It's quite the opposite actually.
That would be my definition and pretty much text book definition. But Garrett apologists tend to imply or cater the definition to some dumbed down version based on what actually happens here in Dallas.
against college competition. theres a reason even when he was back from injury last yr he didnt get much playing time. He just couldnt match up
RKG has nothing to do with giving someone a shot. I think the term is dumb because it never gets followed here in Dallas.
Well, he's 20 lbs bigger and was a rookie coming off an injury. That's what happens to rookies, especially at his position going up against the biggest guy on the field. They need that offseason or too and that NFL weight room/trainer.
His strength will be fine. He's a speed player as well, so when your wheels are busted it affects you greatly.
If Gregory is a pass rusher getting 10+ sacks for the next 3 years he will get plenty of guaranteed money, weed problem be damned. Look at Justin Houston. He tested positive for weed at the combine. He has produced since and that fool got a crazy deal
20lbs? Where did u get that? at the combine Gregory was 235 Dallas cowboys list him at 240. He is what he is. Dallas just made a bad pick.
Here's what I'm getting at though. He's not wrong in saying you want RKG's. You want as many as you can get on your team. It's just very difficult to have a team 100% full of them. If 1 exists at all.
So what happens in Dallas pretty much happens with the rest of the league, it just gets blown up more here because it's the Cowboys. Every team has their "issue" players and that's before or after you draft them. The smarter teams have the better internal support systems to attempt to overcome these challenges and compete.
Every team has an internal support system. How good? That's the question. It's the NFL where guys are star athletes, smash one another and have all kinds of pressure. Coaches and FO's deal with all kinds of ego's and icons. From what I'm hearing, Randy Gregory is a coachable good kid that needs to take all that's bothering him inside out on defenses. That's coming from coach Leon Lett.