Rank our WR's

[Cowboy Brian]

Who has the most talent (how good they currently are) and who has the most potential, i'll start



Talent:
Miles Austin *
Patrick Crayton
Kevin Ogletree
Roy Williams
Sam Hurd
Manuel Johnson
Jesse Holley

Potential:
Miles Austin **
Kevin Ogletree *
Patrick Crayton
Roy Williams
Jesse Holley
Sam Hurd
Manuel Johnson


*= Elite
**= All Pro-Status

 

[Cowboy Brian]

and by Elite I mean a top 25 WR in the NFL and by All-Pro I mean top 3 in conference.

 

[gmsquid]

Who has the most talent (how good they currently are) and who has the most potential, i'll start



Talent:
Miles Austin *
Patrick Crayton
Kevin Ogletree
Roy Williams
Sam Hurd
Manuel Johnson
Jesse Holley

Potential:
Miles Austin **
Kevin Ogletree *
Patrick Crayton
Roy Williams
Jesse Holley
Sam Hurd
Manuel Johnson


*= Elite
**= All Pro-Status

Umm...no:

Talent:
Roy Williams
Miles Austin
Patrick Crayton
Kevin Ogletree
Sam Hurd

Potential:
Miles Austin
Roy Williams
Patrick Crayton
Kevin Ogletree
Sam Hurd

Whether he's performing or not Roy Williams is the best natural talent in our corps, and we don't have one elite receiver or all-pro.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

Umm...no:

Talent:
Roy Williams
Miles Austin
Patrick Crayton
Kevin Ogletree
Sam Hurd

Potential:
Miles Austin
Roy Williams
Patrick Crayton
Kevin Ogletree
Sam Hurd

Whether he's performing or not Roy Williams is the best natural talent in our corps, and we don't have one elite receiver or all-pro.

Williams has nothing, Austin will be a all-pro WR eventually and Ogletree has the potential to follow in Austin's footsteps in a few years.

 

[big dog cowboy]

Sorry but currently Ogletree is not more talented than Williams. Who knows what he could potentially turn into in a couple of years. But currently? No.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

Sorry but currently Ogletree is not more talented than Williams. Who knows what he could potentially turn into in a couple of years. But currently? No.

The two mistakes Williams made against Greenbay im confident Ogletree could've not fumbled and had the key First Down, if Ogletree was in Williams shoes we would've won that game, and im confident in that.

 

[jimmy40]

Who has the most talent (how good they currently are) and who has the most potential, i'll start



Talent:
Miles Austin *
Patrick Crayton
Kevin Ogletree
Roy Williams
Sam Hurd
Manuel Johnson
Jesse Holley

Potential:
Miles Austin **
Kevin Ogletree *
Patrick Crayton
Roy Williams
Jesse Holley
Sam Hurd
Manuel Johnson


*= Elite
**= All Pro-Status

How can Austin be all that when he can't get off the line of scrimmage?

 

[Cowboy Brian]

How can Austin be all that when he can't get off the line of scrimmage?

Remove him from the Cowboys and we are 4-6, hes Elite.

Philly = Game Winning play
Atlanta = over 170 yards, multiple TDs, he won the game
KC = 250+ yards, game winning play and other TDs


Thats pretty elite to me.

 

[DaBoys4Life]

Who has the most talent (how good they currently are) and who has the most potential, i'll start



Talent:
Miles Austin *
Patrick Crayton
Kevin Ogletree
Roy Williams
Sam Hurd
Manuel Johnson
Jesse Holley

Potential:
Miles Austin **
Kevin Ogletree *
Patrick Crayton
Roy Williams
Jesse Holley
Sam Hurd
Manuel Johnson


*= Elite
**= All Pro-Status

This is extremely bias where are the trash and garbage and not NFL WR categories at?

 

[Cowboy Brian]

This is extremely bias where are the trash and garbage and not NFL WR categories at?

lmao, Williams is the only one that fits into both!

 

[DaBoys4Life]

lmao, Williams is the only one that fits into both!

After yesterdays performance they all fit that mold.

 

[jimmy40]

Remove him from the Cowboys and we are 4-6, hes Elite.

Philly = Game Winning play
Atlanta = over 170 yards, multiple TDs, he won the game
KC = 250+ yards, game winning play and other TDs


Thats pretty elite to me.

and now that the NFL knows who he is? stuck at the line of scrimmage

 

[big dog cowboy]

The two mistakes Williams made against Greenbay im confident Ogletree could've not fumbled and had the key First Down, if Ogletree was in Williams shoes we would've won that game, and im confident in that.

You are confusing talent and the way they are playing now. Those are completely different things. I agree Williams isn't playing well now. But that doesn't mean Ogletree is more talented.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

and now that the NFL knows who he is? stuck at the line of scrimmage

Remove austin and we could've lost yesterday, infact we more than likely did, stats don't mean ability to play, 4 catches for 46 yards, moving the chains is great for a #1 WR, he is able to step up when we need him to.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

You are confusing talent and the way they are playing now. Those are completely different things. I agree Williams isn't playing well now. But that doesn't mean Ogletree is more talented.

I think Ogletree has elite potential, Williams does not, Williams has potential to be a good WR in the NFL but not a top 25 WR, Ogletree has that sort of potential.

 

[jimmy40]

I think Ogletree has elite potential, Williams does not, Williams has potential to be a good WR in the NFL but not a top 25 WR, Ogletree has that sort of potential.

based on what?

 

[DaBoys4Life]

Remove austin and we could've lost yesterday, infact we more than likely did, stats don't mean ability to play, 4 catches for 46 yards, moving the chains is great for a #1 WR, he is able to step up when we need him to.

But we wouldn't be in the predicament we were yesterday if our WR's weren't bums of UDFA's that can't get off the line of scrimmage dropping passing because their too high and other non sense that was going on.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

based on what?

When Ogletree had the opportunity, he made plays, he was our team during the pre-season games.

 

[big dog cowboy]

I think Ogletree has elite potential, Williams does not, Williams has potential to be a good WR in the NFL but not a top 25 WR, Ogletree has that sort of potential.

I never said he didn't.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

But we wouldn't be in the predicament we were yesterday if our WR's weren't bums of UDFA's that can't get off the line of scrimmage dropping passing because their too high and other non sense that was going on.

Ok, so if we had fitzgerald we won yesterday with more dominance, but we still are 4-6, not a fair trade to me.