Rank the playoff QBs

PA Cowboy Fan

Well-Known Member
Messages
25,273
Reaction score
51,139
I've never liked his game.

Every once in a while, he looks awesome. But he always follows it up with yuck.

And then, there's that face.
He's had 2 real good runs and the rest of the time he's either been average or below average.
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
Do not care about AFC

NFC

Ryan 69% completion 38 td 7 int
Rodgers 65% 40 td 7 int
Dak 67% 23 td 4 int
Stafford 65% 24 td 10 ints
Wilson 64% 21 td 11 ints
Manning 63% 26 td 16 ints

I put more importance on ints, Turnovers are the killer and in post season even more so. Because of the high TD to int rate of Ryan and Rodgers I rate them higher than Dak
 

alicetooljam

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,063
Reaction score
1,784
LOL at the people ranking Romo near the top. I am not saying you are wrong, but if that is the case, why in the world isn't he starting?

Team chemistry, the hot hand, the future is now....take your pick.
 

erod

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,441
Reaction score
59,818
Do not care about AFC

NFC

Ryan 69% completion 38 td 7 int
Rodgers 65% 40 td 7 int
Dak 67% 23 td 4 int
Stafford 65% 24 td 10 ints
Wilson 64% 21 td 11 ints
Manning 63% 26 td 16 ints

I put more importance on ints, Turnovers are the killer and in post season even more so. Because of the high TD to int rate of Ryan and Rodgers I rate them higher than Dak

But look what's around those quarterbacks. Wilson is running for his life with no run game at all. Stafford kinda the same. Manning's offensive line is trash, too.

Situations have as much to do with numbers as the quarterbacks themselves.
 

JD_KaPow

jimnabby
Messages
11,069
Reaction score
10,833
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Dak has never played in a playoff game. To put him over a 2x super bowl winning QB is asinine.

Eli is much better in the playoffs than he is in the regular season.
Manning has a career passer rating in the postseason of 89. He's the same guy in the playoffs that he is in the regular season. He's had some good games, some horrible games, some bad games that his team won anyway, and so forth. He also hasn't been in the playoffs in 5 years, and part of the reason for that is that he's not a very good QB.
 

erod

Well-Known Member
Messages
38,441
Reaction score
59,818
No.
He left.
Probably because YOU blocked him:muttley:

Maybe there's a Dak fan site out there for him, where you pull for him and don't have to be a Cowboy fan.:grin:

I'm betting on incarceration, didn't pay the internet bill, or got his first girlfriend.
 

JD_KaPow

jimnabby
Messages
11,069
Reaction score
10,833
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Do not care about AFC

NFC

Ryan 69% completion 38 td 7 int
Rodgers 65% 40 td 7 int
Dak 67% 23 td 4 int
Stafford 65% 24 td 10 ints
Wilson 64% 21 td 11 ints
Manning 63% 26 td 16 ints

I put more importance on ints, Turnovers are the killer and in post season even more so. Because of the high TD to int rate of Ryan and Rodgers I rate them higher than Dak
Note also that Dak has 4 lost fumbles: Rodgers and Ryan each have only 2.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
59,798
Reaction score
48,615
Manning has a career passer rating in the postseason of 89. He's the same guy in the playoffs that he is in the regular season. He's had some good games, some horrible games, some bad games that his team won anyway, and so forth. He also hasn't been in the playoffs in 5 years, and part of the reason for that is that he's not a very good QB.
People really don't realize this.

Eli has had some absolutely abysmal playoff years to go with the two lucky, uh, I mean magical ones.
In fact, all of them except those two have been terrible.

They've made the playoffs 5 times in his career.
Outside of those great runs in 2007 and 2011, here are his playoff QB ratings
35.0...insanely bad. result: one and done
85.6...jag-level. result: one and done
40.7...insanely bad. result: one and done
 
Last edited:

WillieBeamen

BoysfanfromNY
Messages
16,018
Reaction score
46,570
Eli has won championships, Dak has not


No Rookie QB has ever won the Super Bowl.


Look i hate the guy (Eli), but if I have to decide whether go with the proven vs the unproven, im going with the proven.
 
Top