DallasEast, my mistake, I thought the list was from wikipedia itself. That's what I get for skimming the OP!
I admit that my vision of Superman was heavily influenced by Richard Donner and company, however I welcomed the idea of a less campy effort. I was thrilled with Snyder's teaser and trailers, but I was disappointed with the film itself. The opening Kryptonian scenes were way too long and involved for my tastes (again, it probably had something to do with the quick 10 minute Krypton look I remember by Donner).
I would rank it below Superman 1 and 2, but above 3 and 4 (and SR of course) Probably high 20s on your list.
Admittedly, my ranking for Man Of Steel is above paid critic (55%) and general audience (approximately 70%-75%) consensus opinion as recorded by movie websites like MetaCritic, RottenTomatoes, and IMDB. My opinion of the movie's entertainment value runs more along with how the character is portrayed in the DC Comics titles (I.e. Action Comics, Superman, etc.) than the way he was conceptionalized in the late 70's on film.
