Started playing this over the last few days. I must say I'm very impressed over all.
I'm not terribly far into the game, and I never played the first one so I went into this totally cold and blind as to what kind of game this might be. It started out a little slow for me. It was honestly in danger, in the beginning, of losing my interest to the point that I wasn't going to play through it. But I decided to give it a real go and finish out a lot of side stuff and such here in Chapter 2 and just see if it grows on me.
Now I'm getting to where I believe must be close to the end of Chapter 2 and I'm really enjoying the game. There are some things I wish were better. I feel like the movement is very...sluggish. I'm just really not a fan of the movement at all. A lot of times I feel like you just move way to slow. Now that is a personal bias, for me, cause I hate slow moving, even when I'm running, characters. I like to run everywhere For example in games like Wild Lands, Far Cry, etc. that are open world I run everywhere. I very rarely use vehicles or anything. I like to run, and explore.
With this game that's just not feasible because you move far to slowly on foot and your stuff, even as you level up, runs out way to fast to get anywhere. I do like the movement on horseback so at least that is better but it could definitely benefit from better moving mechanics. IMHO.
But really outside that I enjoy it. I love the hunting feature. I haven't fished yet but hunting is fun. I love the gun play, for the most part, I think I'd enjoy it more from first person but that's just a person preference more then anything game related.
So far it's a really great game that I'm enjoying. Interesting characters and story. Definitely would recommend it to people for sure.