Some players, like Hardy, need real leadership. This boy had talent. Jimmy Johnson or Ole Tom would have found a way to manage him to their and the clubs benefit. The Cowboys have a weak HC that failed to use Hardy's skills to the clubs advantage. Johnson managed far more difficult players (Haley) Landry had many...Harvey Martin to name one...they got the most out them. To me, Garrett lost a decent asset.
I don't think Garrett ever wanted him here honestly-- and that is a large part of the problem. JJ continually adds talented but troubled players that his HC doesn't want here-- and that's doomed to fail. TO was another one. BP wanted no part of the sideshow, but his owner/GM sees it otherwise and makes a determination.
I am not a Garrett apologist by any stretch. I would feel a lot better if JJ let his HC own these decisions though. In general, people perform better when they are given ownership in a vision or decision. I think too many times coaches are dictated to and undermined in Dallas. Johnson was a strong personality and pushed back and was fired.
BP was a strong personality-- but was too tired and walked away lol. Could someone strong have worked with Hardy? Sure. But IMO-- the writing was on the wall when we signed him and the decision has a small chance of ever working here.