khiladi
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 37,983
- Reaction score
- 39,315
1. Nothing you said, or that you say the doctor said, contradicts what I wrote. Saying it is a normal football injury just means that it is something that is seen in football, not that all players are equally susceptible regardless of age, strength, muscle tone, bone strength etc ....
2. You actually did say the hit was crossing the line (your words ... "technically the hit was crossing the line of dirty ..."). You didn't say those were the words of others, you wrote those words yourself. And, I disagree with them. "Technically" a slide has to occur early enough for the defender to have an opportunity to pull up. "Techinically" if the slide doesn't occur that early, there is no penalty. And that applies to preseason just like it does to regular season. There isn't a separate set of rules for preseason.
Even aside from the penalty aspect, how can it be "dirty" if a player starts a tackle before or simultaneous with the QB starting his slide? "Dirty" suggests intent, and if he started the process of the tackle with no knowledge of the slide, there was no intent.
Please provide for me what the doctor said, when the only words you used were ‘football trauma’.. please show me where you quoted the doctor what he actually meant and not what OmerV said he meant..
So not only does OmverV tell me what I mean, he has a keen ability to tell us what the spine doctors I quoted said in multiple posts means, without even reading what they themselves qualify they mean when using it..
And that too after Romo didn’t have surgery and was practicing by 8 weeks and throwing lasers all over the field, meaning all the practical evidence confirmed what the doctor said., but you know OmerV knows what the doctor said..

worthy. A trainwreck in every debate.