How does he look if Miles Austin catches a pass that was tossed 40 yards downfield, right beyond the outstretched fingers of a diving defender right into the WR's hands? How does he look if Miles Austin runs the route sharply and catches the ball for a first down instead of letting Dre Bly beat him to the spot for an INT? How does he look if Sam Hurd holds on to the football instead of fumbling, and they continue to drive down the field? How does he look if Jason Witten holds onto a ball that hit him right in the bread basket? How does he look if he has TO and Terry Glenn going up against Champ Bailey and Dre Bly for an entire half instead of Sam Hurd and Miles Austin?
Its a little hard to be too critical of him.