cowboys5
Benched
- Messages
- 278
- Reaction score
- 0
irvin4evs;2691308 said:Williams is galaxies away from Fitzgerald's level.
false
irvin4evs;2691308 said:Williams is galaxies away from Fitzgerald's level.
jterrell;2691411 said:a couple of points here.
1) How many times are we going to see this same thread pop up with this same video?
2) Roy Williams has never been considered an elite speed guy. He wasn't at Texas where he was the 3rd fastest high school WR they signed, he wasn't in Detroit where he was their size guy to run slants and he certainly wasn't last year.
3) RW is not slow but he doesn't have explosive speed and isn't a WR whose game is about speed. He is a guy who goes and gets the ball and uses his body as well as anyone to shield defenders.
4) Patrick Crayton has long TD plays and he is a 4.65 guy. Recall how he burned the Commander secondary a few years back?
5) We don't need RW to be a 4.3 WR. We need him to be a first down machine. Austin can fly, Felix Jones can fly and we have a ton of draft picks to go add another depth WR with speed. We need our lead WR to catch everything thrown his way and keep the chains moving so we become more efficient. RW is not going to replace T.O.'s speed and we do not need him to.
jterrell;2691411 said:a couple of points here.
1) How many times are we going to see this same thread pop up with this same video?
2) Roy Williams has never been considered an elite speed guy. He wasn't at Texas where he was the 3rd fastest high school WR they signed, he wasn't in Detroit where he was their size guy to run slants and he certainly wasn't last year.
3) RW is not slow but he doesn't have explosive speed and isn't a WR whose game is about speed. He is a guy who goes and gets the ball and uses his body as well as anyone to shield defenders.
4) Patrick Crayton has long TD plays and he is a 4.65 guy. Recall how he burned the Commander secondary a few years back?
5) We don't need RW to be a 4.3 WR. We need him to be a first down machine. Austin can fly, Felix Jones can fly and we have a ton of draft picks to go add another depth WR with speed. We need our lead WR to catch everything thrown his way and keep the chains moving so we become more efficient. RW is not going to replace T.O.'s speed and we do not need him to.
Bold -->jterrell;2691411 said:a couple of points here.
1) How many times are we going to see this same thread pop up with this same video?
2) Roy Williams has never been considered an elite speed guy. He wasn't at Texas where he was the 3rd fastest high school WR they signed, he wasn't in Detroit where he was their size guy to run slants and he certainly wasn't last year.
3) RW is not slow but he doesn't have explosive speed and isn't a WR whose game is about speed. He is a guy who goes and gets the ball and uses his body as well as anyone to shield defenders.
4) Patrick Crayton has long TD plays and he is a 4.65 guy. Recall how he burned the Commander secondary a few years back?
5) We don't need RW to be a 4.3 WR. We need him to be a first down machine. Austin can fly, Felix Jones can fly and we have a ton of draft picks to go add another depth WR with speed. We need our lead WR to catch everything thrown his way and keep the chains moving so we become more efficient. RW is not going to replace T.O.'s speed and we do not need him to.
JeffInDC;2691271 said:Well, according to the NFL Gameday crew, Dawkins didn't play that day. So, maybe hsi stride makes him look slow or something BUT, I've been looking at some of his video in his Lions days. When he get in the open field, people rarely seem to catch him. So, I really don't know what to think. Personally, I hope everyone plays him like he can't outrun anybody OR get deep. If healthy, I see him with these numbers:
70-75 catches, 1150-1200 yards, 10 TD's
ABQCOWBOY;2691274 said:I've watched Roy Williams for a long time. The problem with Roy is perception right now. Roy Williams has exceptional 100 speed. He is not a quick, 40 guy. If he can get his legs extended, you will not catch him from behind but he's never going to be a quick guy. Randy Moss is like this as well. I don't believe any of the Dallas fan base has seen the real Roy Williams but I won't try to convince. I expect Roy to come out healthy this season and I think you will see a different WR. However, the proof is always in the putting so we will see what we will see.
I'm pulling for him.
AKATheRake;2691425 said:There are things in this post that I will agree with you but you sound a little to sure about this WR core. Austin, Hurd, Stanback all have durability issues. Crayton has mild and so does RW. Austin has never started an NFL game and the most passes he's caught in a season are 13. He's going into his 4th season now and no matter what excuses or how much potential Austin has, those are the facts about his career.
I think RW is a quality WR and Austin has somepotential. Crayton can grind out some needed catches in the slot but you have too much faith in a WR corps that hasn't proven much. It's most proven player is RW and he's 3 years removed from the pro bowl and a 1,000 yard season now that we'll be starting 2009 soon. There will be durability concerns at WR this season if we leave the position as is. History with the players we have says so. I'm not convinced no matter how convicted you saound in your words. Would appreciate some information to back up from what I percieve to be a gutshot feeling you have about the WR core of this team. Don't like its current odds at all.
AKATheRake;2691425 said:There are things in this post that I will agree with you but you sound a little to sure about this WR core. Austin, Hurd, Stanback all have durability issues. Crayton has mild and so does RW. Austin has never started an NFL game and the most passes he's caught in a season are 13. He's going into his 4th season now and no matter what excuses or how much potential Austin has, those are the facts about his career.
I think RW is a quality WR and Austin has somepotential. Crayton can grind out some needed catches in the slot but you have too much faith in a WR corps that hasn't proven much. It's most proven player is RW and he's 3 years removed from the pro bowl and a 1,000 yard season now that we'll be starting 2009 soon. There will be durability concerns at WR this season if we leave the position as is. History with the players we have says so. I'm not convinced no matter how convicted you saound in your words. Would appreciate some information to back up from what I percieve to be a gutshot feeling you have about the WR core of this team. Don't like its current odds at all.
jterrell;2691849 said:I am not sold on it either.
I am simply suggesting we don't need to turn RW into Joey Galloway. Fitzgerald isn't all that fast. But it doesn't matter. RW uses his body well and doesn't need to be 3 yards away from a defender to make a catch.
And to be clear I expect Felix Jones to give teams headaches and Austin, whenever he is the game, to stretch the field. But I am fine playing old school first down football and that's what I grew up with. It worked for the 90's Cowboys who had the "slow" but indefensible Michael Irvin.
JeffInDC;2691235 said:For those folks that think Williams isn't fast (when healthy), just go to the following link:
http://www.nfl.com/videos?categoryI...92306&week=3&seasonFilter=2007&seasonType=REG
It's the '07 Lions vs Eagles game when he takes a 10-12 yard slant 91 yards. Huh, he looked pretty damn fast to me ya'll.
Quarterback Coach;2691870 said:Yeah...well...we don't run any patterns that aren't at least 30 yards downfield in which the line must block for 5 minutes in the Garrett game plan...oh, and we run 5 times a game too.
ABQCOWBOY;2691274 said:I've watched Roy Williams for a long time. The problem with Roy is perception right now. Roy Williams has exceptional 100 speed. He is not a quick, 40 guy. If he can get his legs extended, you will not catch him from behind but he's never going to be a quick guy. Randy Moss is like this as well. I don't believe any of the Dallas fan base has seen the real Roy Williams but I won't try to convince. I expect Roy to come out healthy this season and I think you will see a different WR. However, the proof is always in the putting so we will see what we will see.
I'm pulling for him.
JeffInDC;2691235 said:For those folks that think Williams isn't fast (when healthy), just go to the following link:
http://www.nfl.com/videos?categoryI...92306&week=3&seasonFilter=2007&seasonType=REG
It's the '07 Lions vs Eagles game when he takes a 10-12 yard slant 91 yards. Huh, he looked pretty damn fast to me ya'll.
That is a great post.AKATheRake;2691425 said:There are things in this post that I will agree with you but you sound a little to sure about this WR core. Austin, Hurd, Stanback all have durability issues. Crayton has mild and so does RW. Austin has never started an NFL game and the most passes he's caught in a season are 13. He's going into his 4th season now and no matter what excuses or how much potential Austin has, those are the facts about his career.
I think RW is a quality WR and Austin has some potential. Crayton can grind out some needed catches in the slot but you have too much faith in a WR corps that hasn't proven much. It's most proven player is RW and he's 3 years removed from the pro bowl and a 1,000 yard season now that we'll be starting 2009 soon. There will be durability concerns at WR this season if we leave the position as is. History with the players we have says so. Don't like its current odds at all.