RUMOR: Roy Williams for Roy Williams swap after June 1?

[Arch Stanton]

Why trade for Roy Williams, when come July/August we can get the great Matt Jones for nothing?!

 

[ThreeSportStar80]

If they are stupid enough to make that trade then I would welcome it with open arms...

 

[Idgit]

Why trade for Roy Williams, when come July/August we can get the great Matt Jones for nothing?!

Wait, I thought we were going to trade Williams and Ellis for Matt Jones, to make sure we got him and he never hit the open market.

 

[Nav22]

It's funny... just a few years ago, I used to mockingly refer to Detroit's Roy Williams as "Fake Roy". Turns out, Fake Roy plays for Dallas.

 

[Sarge]

This would be a bigger raping then the Herschel Walker Trade, j/k.

Roy Williams is not going anywhere.

Put me in the minority, but I would not even be suprised if he finished his career in Dallas.

I'll take that bet right now.

 

[CrazyCowboy]

Jerry Jones would feel guilty for ripping the Lions off so badly.

I am sure Mr. Jones would get over it without Dr. Phil.....

 

[Hostile]

Ellis, yes. Both no. Roy for Roy, no.

Anyone who wouldn't trade Dallas burnt toast for Detroit prime rib is an idiot.

I guess that would be just me, huh?

 

[noletime95]

I guess that would be just me, huh?

Hos.....I have to admit, I'm suprised you wouldn't make that trade. I'm sure your reasons are sound....care to elaborate?

 

[dargonking999]

I guess that would be just me, huh?

Don't worry Hos, i got your back. I wouldn't do it either

 

[Sarge]

Ellis, yes. Both no. Roy for Roy, no.

Hos - you seriously wouldn't trade our Roy for their Roy???

I am really shocked at that - seriously.

I'd do it in a NY minute.

IMO/FWIW...

 

[Hostile]

Hos.....I have to admit, I'm suprised you wouldn't make that trade. I'm sure your reasons are sound....care to elaborate?

Hos - you seriously wouldn't trade our Roy for their Roy???

I am really shocked at that - seriously.

I'd do it in a NY minute.

IMO/FWIW...

I just don't share the prevailing winds theory about how good he is because I think many are over reacting. I do not think our Defense would improve if he were gone because we do not have a viable alternative. In fact I think we would regress.

I also expect him to have a great year this year and a lot of people to eat crow. That is just my opinion, I respect opposing views on it, but reserve the right to make up my own mind. If I'm wrong, well I guess that just means less crow will be served.

I certainly wouldn't give up him and a double digit (albeit one year only) sack producer for a #2 WR. Even if I do like that WR a lot and have a lot of hope invested in his coming here.

 

[Sarge]

I just don't share the prevailing winds theory about how good he is because I think many are over reacting. I do not think our Defense would improve if he were gone because we do not have a viable alternative. In fact I think we would regress.

I also expect a him to have a great year this year and a lot of people to eat crow. That is just my opinion, I respect opposing views on it, but reserve the right to make up my own mind. If I'm wrong, well I guess that just means less crow will be served.

I certainly wouldn't give up him and a double digit (albeit one year only) sack producer for a #2 WR. Even if I do like that WR a lot and have a lot of hope invested in his coming here.

I look at it from a little different perspective. I don't particularly have a large amount of faith in our WR corps. It's a real concern I have. I know you can't go into the season worrying about injuries but if TO goes down.....

I also have less faith in our Roy than you do. I think he's somewhat of a headcase..I think he'll improve - he better . . I just think in general terms, a SS is a lot easier to replace than a quality WR. I'll gladly eat crow though......

I do respect your opinion though even if it is completely wrong.

 

[Clove]

A classic, classy debate between Sarge and Hos. That's how you do it folks.

 

[Hostile]

I look at it from a little different perspective. I don't particularly have a large amount of faith in our WR corps. It's a real concern I have. I know you can't go into the season worrying about injuries but if TO goes down.....

I also have less faith in our Roy than you do. I think he's somewhat of a headcase..I think he'll improve - he better . . I just think in general terms, a SS is a lot easier to replace than a quality WR. I'll gladly eat crow though......

I do respect your opinion though even if it is completely wrong.

I too am concerned with the WR Corps. A lot. I believe age and injuries are the 2 factors that sunk us last year more than any other reason. It's why I sunk so much effort into the hope we would acquire Roy Williams. Otherwise I'd have kept it to myself because I know how badly people over react to speculation, even if it is inside.

I agree a SS is easier to replace than a WR, but we didn't do anything to replace either and if we trade one for the other it still leaves a hole and I don't think it's smart to do that.

I've been completely wrong before as you well know. I ain't skeert of it.