I don't know if this was the scariest moment in my life or not, but at the time, I was scared because I couldn't figure out what it was.
When we were 14 - 16, in our little WV town, when the girls our age would have a slumber party, we would sleep in the cabin/fort/treehouse that we had built in the woods.
They would sneak out and we would meet them and run around. Usually we would take them to the graveyard and scare them and stuff.
One night we were in the graveyard, around 2 in the morning or thereabouts.
We would say to the girls, "listen, what's that?", .. or "look, did you see that?"
They would scream and grab us, and it was always a lot of fun.
Anyway, one night we had scared them, they grabbed and hugged us like always and we were getting ready to leave when one of the girls says, "what is that?"
My buddy and I look over and about 50 yds away, at the foot of a tombstone, behind the flowers, a light, a small glow appeared for a moment and then went away. Looked like it came from the grave.
The girls screamed like always, grabbed us like always, but this time we were scared too.
I look at my buddy and we are like, "WHAT WAS THAT?"
We waited and watched, and it appeared again, and then went away. A small glow at the foot of the gravestone.
We waited and it happened again. The girls were scared like always, but instead of fun, my heart was pounding.
This went on for a while, ... the glow, and then it went away, ... the glow, and then it would go away.
This went on for a while, but long story short, I finally figured out that it had rained a little that night, the tombstone was wet, and the airport beacon was going around and just hitting it at the right angle to reflect a little glow at the bottom. Pretty scary when you are 15 though.
One night we lifted a big 4x8 piece of plywood that was covering an open grave that they were going to use the next day I guess.
We lifted the wood and looked down in the hole and I guess a small possum or coon or something had gotten down in the hole and when those little red eyes looked back at us I dropped that wood and took off and didn't stop running for a while.