Scout's Eye: Randle's Decision Making, Claiborne's Success; More From Week 3

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,523
Reaction score
29,868
  • Tyrone Crawford was asked postgame what role injuries played in the Cowboys’ defeat to the Falcons. Crawford’s answer wasn’t surprising when he said “We just didn’t do our jobs.” As well as this Dallas front seven played in the victory last week against the Eagles, it was the complete opposite on Sunday. Against Philadelphia they were able to control the line of scrimmage and rally to the ball – but there was little of that against Atlanta. The Falcons came into the game without their best running back in Tevin Coleman, but that didn’t slow them down one bit. Like I said in my observations shortly after the game, Devonta Freeman punished the Cowboys with his running style. It didn’t matter whether it was inside or outside, Freeman found holes and finished runs. Fullback Patrick DiMarco also played a significant role in the way the Falcons ran the ball. DiMarco was not only physical blocking on the edges, but he was able to inflict damage inside to Anthony Hitchens andSean Lee with his cut blocks that left the pair scrambling to get back on their feet.
  • If Joseph Randle is going to have any success in this scheme, he is going to need to do a better job of trusting the play and following his blockers. Randle hit the Falcons with some large runs, but he also left some potential yards on the field with poor decisions. One play in question saw Scott Linehan send a call in that was designed for Travis Frederick and Tyler Clutts to get outside and capture the corner -- which they were both able to do. On theplay Randle even got a block from Devin Street, which created even more space to the outside. For some unexplained reason, Randle didn’t follow his blockers to the outside, where things had developed – he veered to the inside where Justin Durrant was standing right there to meet him for a one-yard gain instead of having a shot for a larger gain.
  • Even when this Dallas defense tried to double Julio Jones in coverage, he managed to find a way to beat it. On his long touchdown reception, Tyler Patmon jumped to the outside as if he was expecting help to the inside fromJ.J. Wilcox. I am not sure what Wilcox was thinking, because he was also hanging to the outside -- which gave Jones a free release inside. Just by alignment, Wilcox was beaten and had no shot of rallying to Jones to prevent him from catching the ball.
  • At the time I saw it from the press box, I had my questions why Jason Garrett would use a timeout right before the end of the half with the ball on the Atlanta goal line.
http://www.dallascowboys.com/news/2...ss-more-week-3?campaign=sf13595304+sf13595304
 

RS12

Well-Known Member
Messages
32,523
Reaction score
29,868
Terrance Williams drew Desmond Trufant 16 times in coverage on Sunday. On the day, Trufant held Williams to no catches on two targets. In my opinion, Trufant was the best corner the Falcons have. Talking to a couple of members of their front office after the game – they were surprised that Williams didn’t get more of an opportunity to work on Robert Alford, who is not nearly as talented and tends to give up more plays.

This would be on the OC who is supposed to look for mismatches, or at least favorable matchups. Even Atlanta staff figured this would happen.
 

darthseinfeld

Groupthink Guru
Messages
33,540
Reaction score
38,179
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
Not a knock on Mo who has been a pleasant surprise, but I take everything Broaddus says about him with a grain of salt
 

jnday

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,292
Reaction score
11,422
There is little doubt that there will be several posts that reminds everyone that Broaddus doesn't know what he is talking about even though he is a true professional football man. I like his articles, but some posters seem to feel like they know much more than him. I curse the day that the 22 game film was made available and created these great air chair GMs that question these professionals that have actually worked in the NFL.
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
So JR left some meat on the bone?

He was having trouble running outside, even when the play was designed to go that way. Joe is not a speed guy like DMC or Dunbar, he prefers to go north and south and use his agility to wiggle for big plays. Problem is that he is not a great at making his own holes when the creases get small to nonexistent.
 

Dave_in-NC

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,049
Reaction score
5,132
He was having trouble running outside, even when the play was designed to go that way. Joe is not a speed guy like DMC or Dunbar, he prefers to go north and south and use his agility to wiggle for big plays. Problem is that he is not a great at making his own holes when the creases get small to nonexistent.

All true, plus he has no *** to get the dirty yards we so valued last season. I think he might learn the meat on them bones is tough to chew.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BAT

Picksix

A Work in Progress
Messages
5,198
Reaction score
1,081
Mo didnt play well at all. Id rather see Corey White

You don't know what you're talking about. Atlanta had Jones going primarily against Claiborne in the first half, and he didn't get much. In the second half, they moved him to where he'd be covered by Carr or Patmon, and he started tearing it up. The only thing Mo did wrong yesterday was drop the INT.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,193
Reaction score
64,699
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
There is little doubt that there will be several posts that reminds everyone that Broaddus doesn't know what he is talking about even though he is a true professional football man. I like his articles, but some posters seem to feel like they know much more than him. I curse the day that the 22 game film was made available and created these great air chair GMs that question these professionals that have actually worked in the NFL.

Broaddus was fired by Parcells because Parcells thought he was stupid. True story.

Parcells is a real football expert. Broaddus is not.

Broaddus tried to get any job in football but couldn't. Being a media guy was his last choice. He has said it himself.

There are dumb people in all professions. Having some experience does not make a dummy smart. On the flip side a person with a high IQ can be successful without experience. There are a large number of football fans with a higher IQ than Broaddus.

Ron Wolf was a real football guy when he traded for Herschel Walker. It was a dumb decision. Any fans that thought he got fleeced were right and he was wrong.

For anything that Broaddus says, there are thousands of fans that agree and thousands that disagree. Does that make all fans that agree equivalent to experts if you consider Broaddus an expert?
 

LocimusPrime

Well-Known Member
Messages
34,091
Reaction score
92,903
We need a fullback that inflicts punishment too. It seems that dimarco's cut blocks inflicted damage on hitchens and Lee. Hynoski is still available. He looks like he could hurt some linebackers.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,193
Reaction score
64,699
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
He was having trouble running outside, even when the play was designed to go that way. Joe is not a speed guy like DMC or Dunbar, he prefers to go north and south and use his agility to wiggle for big plays. Problem is that he is not a great at making his own holes when the creases get small to nonexistent.
Randle made something out of nothing multiple times last week.
 

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,193
Reaction score
64,699
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Not when they loaded the box against him. He took nothing and made it worse.

Not on the Eagles game. I need to focus some more on him in the Falcons game before commenting on that one.
 

BAT

Mr. Fixit
Messages
19,443
Reaction score
15,607
Broaddus was fired by Parcells because Parcells thought he was stupid. True story.

Parcells is a real football expert. Broaddus is not.

Broaddus tried to get any job in football but couldn't. Being a media guy was his last choice. He has said it himself.

There are dumb people in all professions. Having some experience does not make a dummy smart. On the flip side a person with a high IQ can be successful without experience. There are a large number of football fans with a higher IQ than Broaddus.

Ron Wolf was a real football guy when he traded for Herschel Walker. It was a dumb decision. Any fans that thought he got fleeced were right and he was wrong.

For anything that Broaddus says, there are thousands of fans that agree and thousands that disagree. Does that make all fans that agree equivalent to experts if you consider Broaddus an expert?

Ron Wolf is smart but Jimmy is smarter. And FYI it wasn't Wolf who traded for Herschel, that was Mike Lynn.
 

jnday

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,292
Reaction score
11,422
Broaddus was fired by Parcells because Parcells thought he was stupid. True story.

Parcells is a real football expert. Broaddus is not.

Broaddus tried to get any job in football but couldn't. Being a media guy was his last choice. He has said it himself.

There are dumb people in all professions. Having some experience does not make a dummy smart. On the flip side a person with a high IQ can be successful without experience. There are a large number of football fans with a higher IQ than Broaddus.

Ron Wolf was a real football guy when he traded for Herschel Walker. It was a dumb decision. Any fans that thought he got fleeced were right and he was wrong.

For anything that Broaddus says, there are thousands of fans that agree and thousands that disagree. Does that make all fans that agree equivalent to experts if you consider Broaddus an expert?

Broadus is not perfect , but I am willing to bet that he has forgot more about the pro game that the wanna be experts on a Cowboys message board.nhebiscetillbgetting a paycheck from a pro team. How many posters can say that? Parcels has said some stupid things from time to time himself.
 
Last edited:

xwalker

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,193
Reaction score
64,699
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Ron Wolf is smart but Jimmy is smarter. And FYI it wasn't Wolf who traded for Herschel, that was Mike Lynn.
Yes, you'te correct. I don't know why I said Wolf because it was definitely Lynn.

Either way my point is the same. Just having a football background is not a guarantee of being football smart.
 
Top