TrueBeliever007;3300824 said:Do you think Sensabaugh will sign with another team and we get the second?
Would you mind, with the potential if it is high enough getting Nate Allen?
Write down your thoughts on this.
SDogo;3300839 said:I think there is a 400 page thread that covers every possible opinion, suggestion, complaint and everything in between on this topic already.
TrueBeliever007;3300824 said:Do you think Sensabaugh will sign with another team and we get the second?
Would you mind, with the potential if it is high enough getting Nate Allen?
Write down your thoughts on this.
Clove;3300933 said:It's so funny how we had several years where the stinking safety couldn't cover, ran him out of town and now we have that in the secondary and guess what? People want both gone.
There is a reason teams want him, we're stupid enough to believe we can roll out one really good player and just roll in the next. Reminds me of the Patriots, they think they can replace anyone, how's that working out for them?
TrueBeliever007;3300824 said:Do you think Sensabaugh will sign with another team and we get the second?
Would you mind, with the potential if it is high enough getting Nate Allen?
Write down your thoughts on this.
theogt;3300354 said:He was only thrown at 15 times in 2009, and 26 times in 2008. So, touching the ball 5 times in 41 attempts isn't actually that shocking. You'd like to see him get to the ball more often, but if it's offset by him now allowing much yardage, then that's fine.
For example, Darren Sharper, who most people would say is up there in the top safeties in the league right now, touched the ball 16 times in 76 attempts in the past two seasons. That's not significantly better, but it is better.
But then you look at their yardage given up, and Sharper gave up nearly twice as many yards as Hamlin (565 v. 335). So the question becomes -- would you like him to touch the ball more often at the expense of giving up lots of yardage?
dbair1967;3301033 said:My problem with this logic is you are doing nothing to debunk the fact that he's rarely thrown at because he's almost never in man to man coverage. His coverage responsibilities are usually playing the deep middle or providing double team help over the top. If the guy has few coverage responsibilities (he isnt guarding a specific player) then he should be able to roam around and make plays on the ball in space. Nobody touched the ball less at the FS position than Hamlin.
I ran down each teams starting FS's and looked at some of the numbers for ints and passes defensed. Only a small number (noted in bold) had numbers of pds and ints (combined) as poor as Hamlin's, and those guys played on arguably the worst defenses and worst teams in the league. The vast majority of these guys didnt play on teams as good as we were fefensively, and certainly didnt have the type of pass rush and CB play that we had.
Jairus Byrd Bills. 9 ints, 11 passes defensed. (Missed two games, Rookie)
Antrell Rolle Cardinals...8 PDs, 4 picks
Erik Coleman, Falcons...0 picks, 5 PD's
Ed Reed, Ravens...5 pds, 3 picks (missed 4 full games, parts of others)
Charles Godfrey 5pds, 1 pick...(missed 4 full games, parts of a couple others and one other note his backup Sherrod Martin had 3 picks and 4 pds)
Daniel Manning, Bears...2 pds, 1 pick
Chris Crocker Bengals, 9 pds, 2 picks
Abram Elam Browns, 2 pds, 0 picks
Brian Dawkins Broncos, 11 pds, 2 picks
Louis Delmas Lions, 8 pds, 2 picks (Rookie)
Nick Collins Packers, 13 pds, 6 picks
Jon Busing Texans, 3 pds, 1 pick
Antoine Bethea 5 pds, 4 picks
Reggie Nelson Jags, 5 pds, 0 picks
Jon McGraw Chiefs, 1 pd, 1 pick
Gibril Wilson Dolphins, 8 pds, 0 picks
Madieu Williams Vikings, 8 pds, 0 picks
Brandon McGowan Pats, 5 pds, 0 picks
Darren Sharper Saints, 15 pds, 9 picks
CC Brown Giants, 3 pds, 0 picks
Kerry Rhodes Jets, 13 pds, 3 picks (was benched)
Michael Huff Raiders, 14 pds, 3 picks
Sean Jones Eagles, 5 pds, 2 picks (was 1 of 3 different starters)
Ryan Clark Steelers, 8pds, 3 picks
Eric Weddle Chargers, 7pds, 2 picks
Dashon Goldsen Niners, 6 pds, 4 picks
Jordan Babineaux Seahawks, 6pds, 2 picks
Craig Dahl Rams, 3 pds, 0 picks
Tanard Jackson Bucs, 8 pds, 5 picks (missed 4 full games)
Michael Griffin Titans, 7pds, 1 pick
Laron Landry Commanders 6 pds, 1 pick
What's funny is that you don't even get the inconsistency in your argument. If you think his coverage responsibilities are the reason he's not targeted much, you have to grant that his coverage responsibilities are the reason doesn't have many INTs. You can't have your cake and eat it too.dbair1967;3301033 said:My problem with this logic is you are doing nothing to debunk the fact that he's rarely thrown at because he's almost never in man to man coverage. His coverage responsibilities are usually playing the deep middle or providing double team help over the top. If the guy has few coverage responsibilities (he isnt guarding a specific player) then he should be able to roam around and make plays on the ball in space. Nobody touched the ball less at the FS position than Hamlin.
I ran down each teams starting FS's and looked at some of the numbers for ints and passes defensed. Only a small number (noted in bold) had numbers of pds and ints (combined) as poor as Hamlin's, and those guys played on arguably the worst defenses and worst teams in the league. The vast majority of these guys didnt play on teams as good as we were defensively, and certainly didnt have the type of pass rush and CB play that we had.
Jairus Byrd Bills. 9 ints, 11 passes defensed. (Missed two games, Rookie)
Antrell Rolle Cardinals...8 PDs, 4 picks
Erik Coleman, Falcons...0 picks, 5 PD's
Ed Reed, Ravens...5 pds, 3 picks (missed 4 full games, parts of others)
Charles Godfrey 5pds, 1 pick...(missed 4 full games, parts of a couple others and one other note his backup Sherrod Martin had 3 picks and 4 pds)
Daniel Manning, Bears...2 pds, 1 pick
Chris Crocker Bengals, 9 pds, 2 picks
Abram Elam Browns, 2 pds, 0 picks
Brian Dawkins Broncos, 11 pds, 2 picks
Louis Delmas Lions, 8 pds, 2 picks (Rookie)
Nick Collins Packers, 13 pds, 6 picks
Jon Busing Texans, 3 pds, 1 pick
Antoine Bethea 5 pds, 4 picks
Reggie Nelson Jags, 5 pds, 0 picks
Jon McGraw Chiefs, 1 pd, 1 pick
Gibril Wilson Dolphins, 8 pds, 0 picks
Madieu Williams Vikings, 8 pds, 0 picks
Brandon McGowan Pats, 5 pds, 0 picks
Darren Sharper Saints, 15 pds, 9 picks
CC Brown Giants, 3 pds, 0 picks
Kerry Rhodes Jets, 13 pds, 3 picks (was benched)
Michael Huff Raiders, 14 pds, 3 picks
Sean Jones Eagles, 5 pds, 2 picks (was 1 of 3 different starters)
Ryan Clark Steelers, 8pds, 3 picks
Eric Weddle Chargers, 7pds, 2 picks
Dashon Goldsen Niners, 6 pds, 4 picks
Jordan Babineaux Seahawks, 6pds, 2 picks
Craig Dahl Rams, 3 pds, 0 picks
Tanard Jackson Bucs, 8 pds, 5 picks (missed 4 full games)
Michael Griffin Titans, 7pds, 1 pick
Laron Landry Commanders 6 pds, 1 pick
Here are the rankings of these safeties in terms of PDs and INTs per times targeted. Hamlin ranks about average for starting safeties.dbair1967;3301033 said:My problem with this logic is you are doing nothing to debunk the fact that he's rarely thrown at because he's almost never in man to man coverage. His coverage responsibilities are usually playing the deep middle or providing double team help over the top. If the guy has few coverage responsibilities (he isnt guarding a specific player) then he should be able to roam around and make plays on the ball in space. Nobody touched the ball less at the FS position than Hamlin.
I ran down each teams starting FS's and looked at some of the numbers for ints and passes defensed. Only a small number (noted in bold) had numbers of pds and ints (combined) as poor as Hamlin's, and those guys played on arguably the worst defenses and worst teams in the league. The vast majority of these guys didnt play on teams as good as we were defensively, and certainly didnt have the type of pass rush and CB play that we had.
Jairus Byrd Bills. 9 ints, 11 passes defensed. (Missed two games, Rookie)
Antrell Rolle Cardinals...8 PDs, 4 picks
Erik Coleman, Falcons...0 picks, 5 PD's
Ed Reed, Ravens...5 pds, 3 picks (missed 4 full games, parts of others)
Charles Godfrey 5pds, 1 pick...(missed 4 full games, parts of a couple others and one other note his backup Sherrod Martin had 3 picks and 4 pds)
Daniel Manning, Bears...2 pds, 1 pick
Chris Crocker Bengals, 9 pds, 2 picks
Abram Elam Browns, 2 pds, 0 picks
Brian Dawkins Broncos, 11 pds, 2 picks
Louis Delmas Lions, 8 pds, 2 picks (Rookie)
Nick Collins Packers, 13 pds, 6 picks
Jon Busing Texans, 3 pds, 1 pick
Antoine Bethea 5 pds, 4 picks
Reggie Nelson Jags, 5 pds, 0 picks
Jon McGraw Chiefs, 1 pd, 1 pick
Gibril Wilson Dolphins, 8 pds, 0 picks
Madieu Williams Vikings, 8 pds, 0 picks
Brandon McGowan Pats, 5 pds, 0 picks
Darren Sharper Saints, 15 pds, 9 picks
CC Brown Giants, 3 pds, 0 picks
Kerry Rhodes Jets, 13 pds, 3 picks (was benched)
Michael Huff Raiders, 14 pds, 3 picks
Sean Jones Eagles, 5 pds, 2 picks (was 1 of 3 different starters)
Ryan Clark Steelers, 8pds, 3 picks
Eric Weddle Chargers, 7pds, 2 picks
Dashon Goldsen Niners, 6 pds, 4 picks
Jordan Babineaux Seahawks, 6pds, 2 picks
Craig Dahl Rams, 3 pds, 0 picks
Tanard Jackson Bucs, 8 pds, 5 picks (missed 4 full games)
Michael Griffin Titans, 7pds, 1 pick
Laron Landry Commanders 6 pds, 1 pick
Name TA In PD In+PD In+PD/
Jairus Byrd 18 9 1 10 0.56
Nick Collins 29 6 7 13 0.45
Michael Huff 35 3 11 14 0.40
Darren Sharper 37 9 3 12 0.32
Edward Reed 18 3 2 5 0.28
Ryan Clark 26 3 4 7 0.27
Charles Godfrey 18 1 3 4 0.22
Kerry Rhodes 36 3 5 8 0.22
Chris Crocker 31 2 4 6 0.19
Gibril Wilson 31 0 6 6 0.19
Antoine Bethea 26 4 1 5 0.19
Antrel Rolle 34 4 2 6 0.18
Eric Weddle 34 2 4 6 0.18
Madieu Williams 39 0 6 6 0.15
Brian Dawkins 48 2 5 7 0.15
John Busing 14 1 1 2 0.14
[COLOR="Blue"][B]Ken Hamlin 15 0 2 2 0.13 [/B][/COLOR]
Erik Coleman 39 0 5 5 0.13
Michael Griffin 49 1 5 6 0.12
Dashon Goldson 52 4 2 6 0.12
Brandon McGowan 35 0 4 4 0.11
Jon McGraw 18 1 1 2 0.11
LaRon Landry 38 1 3 4 0.11
J. Babineaux 60 2 4 6 0.10
Craig Dahl 41 0 4 4 0.10
Reggie Nelson 41 0 4 4 0.10
Louis Delmas 35 2 1 3 0.09
C.C. Brown 33 0 2 2 0.06
Abram Elam 38 0 2 2 0.05
Danieal Manning 21 1 0 1 0.05
theogt;3301100 said:Here are the rankings of these safeties in terms of PDs and INTs per times targeted. Hamlin ranks about average for starting safeties.
Not exactly "shocking" or deserving of a "wow" is it?Code:Name TA In PD In+PD In+PD/ Jairus Byrd 18 9 1 10 0.56 Nick Collins 29 6 7 13 0.45 Michael Huff 35 3 11 14 0.40 Darren Sharper 37 9 3 12 0.32 Edward Reed 18 3 2 5 0.28 Ryan Clark 26 3 4 7 0.27 Charles Godfrey 18 1 3 4 0.22 Kerry Rhodes 36 3 5 8 0.22 Chris Crocker 31 2 4 6 0.19 Gibril Wilson 31 0 6 6 0.19 Antoine Bethea 26 4 1 5 0.19 Antrel Rolle 34 4 2 6 0.18 Eric Weddle 34 2 4 6 0.18 Madieu Williams 39 0 6 6 0.15 Brian Dawkins 48 2 5 7 0.15 John Busing 14 1 1 2 0.14 [COLOR=Blue][B]Ken Hamlin 15 0 2 2 0.13 [/B][/COLOR] Erik Coleman 39 0 5 5 0.13 Michael Griffin 49 1 5 6 0.12 Dashon Goldson 52 4 2 6 0.12 Brandon McGowan 35 0 4 4 0.11 Jon McGraw 18 1 1 2 0.11 LaRon Landry 38 1 3 4 0.11 J. Babineaux 60 2 4 6 0.10 Craig Dahl 41 0 4 4 0.10 Reggie Nelson 41 0 4 4 0.10 Louis Delmas 35 2 1 3 0.09 C.C. Brown 33 0 2 2 0.06 Abram Elam 38 0 2 2 0.05 Danieal Manning 21 1 0 1 0.05
Combine that with him being at the top of this crowd in terms of yards given up, we have ourself one of the better free safeties in the league.
Thanks for pointing this out.![]()
What someone deserves or "warrants" is hard to define. I think he's a key piece to the performance of our defense and I think that warrants taking steps necessary to keep him around. I think his value might have been inflated when we signed him because people tend to inflate the value of INTs and he had a lot of INTs that season.Bob Sacamano;3301101 said:Do you think his play warrants his contract?
theogt;3301106 said:What someone deserves or "warrants" is hard to define. I think he's a key piece to the performance of our defense and I think that warrants taking steps necessary to keep him around. I think his value might have been inflated when we signed him because people tend to inflate the value of INTs and he had a lot of INTs that season.
If his contract doesn't hinder us in any way, then absolutely I want to keep him around. It'd be remarkably stupid to get rid of him.Bob Sacamano;3301109 said:So with saying that, and his INTs being down,
significantly
You still see a reason for keeping him around at that price?
Doesn't his contract call for him to average around 6 mil per season?
theogt;3301112 said:If his contract doesn't hinder us in any way, then absolutely I want to keep him around. It'd be remarkably stupid to get rid of him.
He will make $5.5 million 2010 and $5 million in 2011. That's only slightly above average for a starting NFL player (which, if I recall correctly, is around $4 million).
Bob Sacamano;3301109 said:So with saying that, and his INTs being down,
significantly
You still see a reason for keeping him around at that price?
Doesn't his contract call for him to average around 6 mil per season?
TheCount;3301119 said:You're wasting your time.