SN magazine asks 99 current players poll ranking most overated players

[theogt]

Ask all 99 players if they'd like to have those players on their roster. It'd be almost unanimous with every player.

 

[vta]

He is the last half of last year and the first half of this year. He has no numbers the last 16 games.

But he's really not even defined by his numbers anymore. The guy is a great WR on the other side of age and a bad attitude. He was never over rated for his ability as a WR. His career is definitely that of an excellent receiver.

How he's covered now is as a buffoon and locker room cancer. No one is touting his game over the last year and half so he's not being over rated.

 

[NextGenBoys]

:laugh2:

Who voted for Mark Sanchez? I'd put my money on Matt Stafford and Josh Freeman.

Does anyone really think highly of Ted Ginn? You can't be overrated if no one thinks you're good.

Romo is a joke. Favre is a joke. TO is a joke. etc, etc

The list is a joke.

Lol dude it's a list of opinions from current NFl players.

Just because it is different from your opinion is far from meaning its a joke.

 

[Cowboy Brian]

I think you can absolutely make a case for TO being overrated if his "rating" is that he is on eof the top 5 WR's in the game today.

His numbers this year clearly say he's not. Perhaps last year's numbers as well.

I'm not hating on him. Its just that he's now, what 35 years old, and not producing like he once did. Is it all his QB's or OC's fault? Honestly, I don't think a reasonable person would say that TO hasn't dropped off as well.

There's your case for overrated.

He hasn't, the play where Buffalo did a variation of the wildcat and gave a handoff to T.O and he had that 29 yard TD last Week was old school T.O, when I saw that play I was craving he was still in Dallas next to Miles, we would be 7-0

 

[big dog cowboy]

I'm shocked Romo didn't get the most votes by a wide margin.

 

[AmishCowboy]

He hasn't, the play where Buffalo did a variation of the wildcat and gave a handoff to T.O and he had that 29 yard TD last Week was old school T.O, when I saw that play I was craving he was still in Dallas next to Miles, we would be 7-0

He just couldn't keep his mouth shut here and became to much of a Distraction, when he spouts off in Buffalo it gets very little attention, here just like Roy's comments, it's front page on ESPN and Whining at Romo for the Ball every play didn't help.

 

[Cowboysfan22]

How is Tony Romo a guy with a 97 QB rating and a 5-2 team overated............just wondering

 

[dozin_theknick]

Really? I didn't know any sports commentators, enthusiasts, coaches, or peers recognized him as an outstanding player.

Where have you been?