SN the magazine survey most overated WRs in the game today

[RS12]

number of votes: Chad Johnson 3
Wes Welker 2
Roy Williams 2
nobody said anything specifically about Roy W in the comments

 

[TheKey]

Its because he plays for Dallas. Last year in Detroit he wouldn't have made the list. Notice there is no T.O, it is because he left Dallas, last year he was on this list.

Haters.

 

[Bleu Star]

Its because he plays for Dallas. Last year in Detroit he wouldn't have made the list. Notice there is no T.O, it is because he left Dallas, last year he was on this list.

Haters.

I don't particularly care for RW11 because he hasn't shown me anything in a Cowboys uni (yet). Does that make me a hater? It would be interesting to be on the opposite end of the star WR debate this year.

Hater out

 

[jobberone]

He's shown a flash here and there.

I think he's going to be better in the red zone this year. If he's ok otherwise then he's golden.

 

[viman96]

IMO RW11 is going to prove a lot of members wrong. Doubtful the majority of will admit it though!

 

[STAR GAZER]

Doubtful the majority of will admit it though!

There are many members on this forum who have selective amnesia. I could name several, who were on various bandwagons in the recent past, and are now boasting completely different opinions.

I'm not naming names of course. :zipit:

 

[Mansta54]

I don't particularly care for RW11 because he hasn't shown me anything in a Cowboys uni (yet). Does that make me a hater? It would be interesting to be on the opposite end of the star WR debate this year.

Hater out

I don't mean any harm but this is such a ridiculous statement. The guy came over to the Boyz in midseason, had to learn a new O, new terminology, get adjusted to new teammates, try to fit in, all while Romo missed his first 3 games when he got here. Not to mention Romo still played hurt when he did return and had TO in his ear on every pass play. RW11 was a monster in Detroit and that's what he should be judged on at this point. He hasn't had a chance to do or prove anything in BIG D just just.....

 

[STAR GAZER]

I don't mean any harm but this is such a ridiculous statement. The guy came over to the Boyz in midseason, had to learn a new O, new terminology, get adjusted to new teammates, try to fit in, all while Romo missed his first 3 games when he got here. Not to mention Romo still played hurt when he did return and had TO in his ear on every pass play. RW11 was a monster in Detroit and that's what he should be judged on at this point. He hasn't had a chance to do or prove anything in BIG D just just.....

Here... here... :toast:

 

[big dog cowboy]

IMO RW11 is going to prove a lot of members wrong. Doubtful the majority of will admit it though!

Now finally healthy, I agree.

 

[Idgit]

I don't mean any harm but this is such a ridiculous statement. The guy came over to the Boyz in midseason, had to learn a new O, new terminology, get adjusted to new teammates, try to fit in, all while Romo missed his first 3 games when he got here. Not to mention Romo still played hurt when he did return and had TO in his ear on every pass play. RW11 was a monster in Detroit and that's what he should be judged on at this point. He hasn't had a chance to do or prove anything in BIG D just just.....

When they went to him last year, he caught everything even close to him.

By the same token, there were a couple of plays aired on tv where RW was isolated and his route was just plain awful. It's hard to say what read he was for most of the plays run last year. Probably no more than third most of the time. It wold be *huge* for this team if we have another legit probowl WR in the prime of his career sitting on our roster already.

 

[Bleu Star]

IMO RW11 is going to prove a lot of members wrong. Doubtful the majority of will admit it though!

I will gladly step up to the plate if he actually pans out. I've eaten crow before. It actually tastes pretty good. A little gamey but otherwise decent.

I don't mean any harm but this is such a ridiculous statement. The guy came over to the Boyz in midseason, had to learn a new O, new terminology, get adjusted to new teammates, try to fit in, all while Romo missed his first 3 games when he got here. Not to mention Romo still played hurt when he did return and had TO in his ear on every pass play. RW11 was a monster in Detroit and that's what he should be judged on at this point. He hasn't had a chance to do or prove anything in BIG D just just.....

No harm taken. As I stated, He still has plenty to prove to me. When he's a monster in a Boys uni I will then find some appreciation of the trade.

 

[5Stars]

I will gladly step up to the plate if he actually pans out. I've eaten crow before. It actually tastes pretty good. A little gamey but otherwise decent.



No harm taken. As I stated, He still has plenty to prove to me. When he's a monster in a Boys uni I will then find some appreciation of the trade.

Yo, Bleu, do me a favor and take that Baseball crap off this board and put it where the sun don't shine or take it to a baseball forum...

k?

 

[Bob Sacamano]

yeah BLEU!

btw, I think Roy is kind of overrated, he's really only had 1 top season, but is being paid like one of the top receivers in the game

 

[tomson75]

IMO RW11 is going to prove a lot of members wrong. Doubtful the majority of will admit it though!

I'd be one of them....and I'll be glad to admit it. I'm crossing my fingers.

 

[Bleu Star]

Yo, Bleu, do me a favor and take that Baseball crap off this board and put it where the sun don't shine or take it to a baseball forum...

k?

Who pissed in your caviar?

 

[BHendri5]

Who and what is SN. Where can I go and read this for myself

 

[Bleu Star]

Who and what is SN. Where can I go and read this for myself

Sporting News?

 

[CATCH17]

Now finally healthy, I agree.

Roy Williams is the least of our worries.

Hes to talented and obviously to motivated now not to have success in a league where he has already had success and not ever been nearly as pushed as he is right now.


My biggest worries this year is which Flozell Adams we get and how well our nickle package does with the loss of Burnett.


Another concern would be Miles Austin.

I think hes got all the potential in the world but we haven't seen it consistently on the field. But i'd bet he will be a good player for us based on what i've seen in the opportunities that he has been given.

 

[STAR GAZER]

Another concern would be Miles Austin.

I think hes got all the potential in the world but we haven't seen it consistently on the field. But i'd bet he will be a good player for us based on what i've seen in the opportunities that he has been given.

If I remember correctly he went undrafted as well. If he continues to perform as he has shown he can, and stays healthy, we have a steal in the making. ray:

 

[Clove]

I don't mean any harm but this is such a ridiculous statement. The guy came over to the Boyz in midseason, had to learn a new O, new terminology, get adjusted to new teammates, try to fit in, all while Romo missed his first 3 games when he got here. Not to mention Romo still played hurt when he did return and had TO in his ear on every pass play. RW11 was a monster in Detroit and that's what he should be judged on at this point. He hasn't had a chance to do or prove anything in BIG D just just.....

When I was in Junior high, they called a 5 yard out, a slant and a go route.

Those routes were still in the play book when I get to high school and then semi pro. Even when I played flag football, somehow we had the same 3 routes in the play book.

If he's not getting away from 1 on 1 coverage, and he can't figure out what an out route, a slant, or a go route is, then he shouldn't be playing in the NFL.