Stuck in limbo still

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member
Messages
58,295
Reaction score
38,881
What's the absolute worst thing that can happen if we're out of it at 0-6 and keep Romo on the bench? We might get a very high draft pick? It's not like Romo would need the game experience at that point. Why risk further injury? By letting Dak play, he not only gets experience but he develops a rapport with guys like Dak, Zeke and the oline, who he could be around for years to come.....
If we go like 0-6 or 1-5 with Dak we're gonna want the top pick cause we won't be sold Dak is the answer . Plus will be too late for Romo to save the season.

Yes, then I agree. Let it play out.
 

ksadler1

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,003
Reaction score
5,383
Looking forward to seeing Dak play a full game with all of our starters. We already know what Romo can do when healthy. Bring on the Giants so that we can settle this dispute.

It's actually kind of ironic that Romo started his career against the Giants too. He didn't start that game but that's when he took over as the starter. His very first pass was a tipped INT.....
 

haleyrules

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,060
Reaction score
42,877
And Why it may ride on how well Dak does and how desperate we become.

If we start out winless the pressure will mount for Romo's return even if he isn't close to a 100%.
Romo will not be close to 100% thats a certainty..he is 36 and basically did not play last year. If he misses say another 6+ how long will it take him to get back in real game shape.
 

ksadler1

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,003
Reaction score
5,383
If we go like 0-6 or 1-5 with Dak we're gonna want the top pick cause we won't be sold Dak is the answer.

Can't argue that. But we would still need to see the circumstances of the losses. We were in position to win several games last year that the D gave away. We can't hold Dak responsible for losses like that if he plays well enough to win.....
 

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member
Messages
58,295
Reaction score
38,881
My instinct is it's probably going to go one extreme or the other .

Dak is either going to catch fire or crash and burn. Which either of those doesn't provide a good situation for Romo's return.

I'm rooting for him to catch fire. But I'm not sure everyone would welcome that QB controversy ?
 

Zimmy Lives

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,165
Reaction score
4,631
It's not really limbo. It's the Dak era now and Tony is done. Believe me, it pains me to say this, but you just have to move on.


"The Age of Romo is over. The Time of the Dak has come."

Sorry, couldn't resist a Lord of The Rings reference. It is the Dak era now but who knows how long it will last. The silver lining is: Now we can find out right away if this kid can play and is the future.
 

ksadler1

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,003
Reaction score
5,383
My instinct is it's probably going to go one extreme or the other .

Dak is either going to catch fire or crash and burn. Which either of those doesn't provide a good situation for Romo's return.

I'm rooting for him to catch fire. But I'm not sure everyone would welcome that QB controversy ?

I'm just hoping he can stay somewhere in-between there this year. Lets face it, he's going to have a few bad games, but every QB does. Even Romo has those head scratcher games a couple times a year.....
 

bayeslife

187beatdown
Messages
9,461
Reaction score
8,584
This must be your first preseason.

Yeah there's been some preseason wonders that have flamed out in the past. Now I haven't exactly seen them do so vs 1s like Dak has but it's not a guarantee
 

CouchCoach

Staff member
Messages
41,122
Reaction score
74,959
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Are we rooting for Dak to have enough success that we won't want Romo to come back?

Sorry for asking the tough questions.
Some are and some are wanting Romo back and some want the best player to play to bring about the best results. Since I am new to this site, I don't have a clue where posters are in that grouping.

Because I've seen for the 4th year in row QB1 out, I am ready for the next phase of the Cowboys. Not blaming him and I do like him as the QB and as a person but I am worn out on the sos and need to move forward with this team. I have 0 faith in Romo's ability to protect himself if he does come back and play. Watching that replay several times told me that he should have already retired.
 

Runwildboys

Confused about stuff
Messages
51,679
Reaction score
96,900
CowboysZone DIEHARD Fan
The Coaches in Washington, and rightfully so, tried to turn him into a pocket passing QB. That was not a strength of his. Dak has more pocket presence that RGIII ever did. RGIII was a run first QB, Dak will run but not as a first option. The term "figuring out a QB" is just that. Yes, QB's have certain tendencies, I can't argue that, but good coaching can overcome that. That's my only concern here. Can the coaching staff help him develop?.....
Believe me, I'm incredibly impressed by what Dak has been doing. He's been playing very well by anyone's standards. I just think it's too soon to determine this is how he'll always play. It certainly is indicative of his potential, but the NFL history is chock full of guys who, for one reason or another, didn't live up to their potential. Just to be clear, I hope he's as good as the most optimistic fan thinks he is, but after 20 years of disappointment I'm tempering my enthusiasm. :)
 
Messages
74
Reaction score
31
This Cowboy QB situation lingers on like a Brett Farve retirement. It's a hangover even Jerry struggles to fight through.

First the realities of Romo. It's a good news/bad news situation.

The good news is, the L1 vertebrae isn't the one that had surgery, nor is it even next to it. It's also not the one that had the transverse fracture two years ago. Essentially, the compression fracture isn't related to the other back issues, and it should heal just fine with no issues, whatever that time frame is.

Romo will be back.

The bad news is, Tony is 36 years old, and that now makes five injuries in less than two years. He ruptured a disc against Washington and required offseason surgery (which involved a cyst, too), then he had the transverse fracture, then he had two broken collar bones (the same bone not yet healed properly), and now this compression fracture to the L1. That's a lot of stuff, but ironically, his shoulder, knees, ankles, etc, are all just fine. No concussions, no hip issues. Romo has golfer's injuries. I wonder if he wished he didn't play so much golf because it obviously wrecked his back.

Now for the realities of Dak Prescott.

We are all giddy about the kid. If he's the "next" one, then glory be, we found him by accident in the fourth round. It's like Romo all over again, coming out of nowhere. You can feel the angst and fist-clenching around the league...those damn Cowboys aren't going into hibernation when Romo's done. They have a future apparently if current form translates.

But let's not kid ourselves. Dak doesn't really know what awaits him just yet. Defensive coordinators stay up all night and break you down, then they implement defensive packages and schemes that young Dak has never seen in his life. If not careful, it could get ugly.

Fortunately, Dak has the best situation a young QB can ask for. A powerful line and a stable of running backs that are the envy of the league. An elite receiver who can go up and get an errant throw. A seasoned tight end to calm the huddle and be a safety valve any time needed. This isn't like what Troy saw as a rookie. Dak has a LOT of help around him. He need not try to do everything himself.

That, and no doubt a little read-option (which I hate) to give him ammo to keep pass rushers at bay even more should make this a workable situation as he learns. Lots of play action and roll-outs. Easy throws to get him in rhythm. Plus, if Zeke can force teams into eight-man fronts, it's harder to disguise coverage. There's plenty of adjustments Linehan can make to get Dak comfortable.

I feel confident Dak can lead this team to at least three wins those first six games before Romo returns. The experience he'll gain will only expedite his progress. The game will slowly slow down.

There's a real QB controversy brewing a year from now. But not yet. And no, the season's hopes are far from over if they can just get Dak settled and comfortable. All the poise on the planet doesn't prepare for the truly unknown.

Meanwhile, as we're accustomed, we wait on Romo. What will he be when he returns? Can that back settle down, and is the collar bone good to go?

At least we know this, and this is HUGE. Romo can play and let it fly because there's finally real hope behind him. I'd rather watch Dak develop live than watch the Weeden/Cassel types flop around like fish in a boat.

Has it ever struck any of you that dak may be just as big of a fish in a boat flopper?
Everyone here assumes he's the real deal because of a few ps games, and you all assume he's the next big thing.. maybe in a few years he will be, but that's a mighty big assumption.
 

CouchCoach

Staff member
Messages
41,122
Reaction score
74,959
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Believe me, I'm incredibly impressed by what Dak has been doing. He's been playing very well by anyone's standards. I just think it's too soon to determine this is how he'll always play. It certainly is indicative of his potential, but the NFL history is chock full of guys who, for one reason or another, didn't live up to their potential. Just to be clear, I hope he's as good as the most optimistic fan thinks he is, but after 20 years of disappointment I'm tempering my enthusiasm. :)
And that pretend season performance may have established unreal expectations for him. Even the ones that I saw cautioning people that it was preseason were on his wagon after that second game.

I am a layman, I know there a big difference between the pretend and real games but just how much I would have to be on the inside. He has really impressed some of the more experienced football people and that has affected my opinion as well because I want to believe that and they know more than I do.

I try to balance this out but I've just never seen a rookie QB that calm and comfortable at his stage of development. Maybe he is something different, something special? One thing for sure, that SEA game sure made this NYG game a lot more interesting.
 

Runwildboys

Confused about stuff
Messages
51,679
Reaction score
96,900
CowboysZone DIEHARD Fan
And that pretend season performance may have established unreal expectations for him. Even the ones that I saw cautioning people that it was preseason were on his wagon after that second game.

I am a layman, I know there a big difference between the pretend and real games but just how much I would have to be on the inside. He has really impressed some of the more experienced football people and that has affected my opinion as well because I want to believe that and they know more than I do.

I try to balance this out but I've just never seen a rookie QB that calm and comfortable at his stage of development. Maybe he is something different, something special? One thing for sure, that SEA game sure made this NYG game a lot more interesting.
I wanna believe, Coach!
 

Blake

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,814
Reaction score
9,391
LOL.......What is sooo great about "right now"?

Dont you see the writing on the wall?

-best young Oline in football
-Zeke at 21
Dak at 21

Its a dream youth movement. The quicker all these guys grow and get confidence together the quicker we become the team we need to be. .

BINGO. Let these young ones develop the chemistry and camaraderie that will make them a formidable force to be reckoned with is my philosophy on this. But if Romo does return, well, more power to him. He has my support also, but realistically, I just envision him taking a reality biting hit that will once and for all cement his retirement.
 

PA Cowboy Fan

Well-Known Member
Messages
25,355
Reaction score
51,350
I think this makes me more nervous for a season opener than I usually would be. I just hope he plays well. I so hope he's our future QB. I couldn't stand to go back to the Quincy-Chad years. That was a nightmare.
 

Blake

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,814
Reaction score
9,391
Has it ever struck any of you that dak may be just as big of a fish in a boat flopper?
Everyone here assumes he's the real deal because of a few ps games, and you all assume he's the next big thing.. maybe in a few years he will be, but that's a mighty big assumption.

Oh look, a Skins troll.:rolleyes:
 

CouchCoach

Staff member
Messages
41,122
Reaction score
74,959
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Has it ever struck any of you that dak may be just as big of a fish in a boat flopper?
Everyone here assumes he's the real deal because of a few ps games, and you all assume he's the next big thing.. maybe in a few years he will be, but that's a mighty big assumption.
No, can't say I have.
 

ksadler1

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,003
Reaction score
5,383
Has it ever struck any of you that dak may be just as big of a fish in a boat flopper?
Everyone here assumes he's the real deal because of a few ps games, and you all assume he's the next big thing.. maybe in a few years he will be, but that's a mighty big assumption.

As much as I like Dak, I also know he could flop. You're absolutely right. Nothing is a sure thing.....
 

CouchCoach

Staff member
Messages
41,122
Reaction score
74,959
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
I wanna believe, Coach!
Yeah, me too, Runny. But I am trying to balance my expectations for this kid and it helps that I watched him quite a bit in college, I wasn't in college, he was. If he makes some of those throws he made last season a lot of this Dak love is going to cool. And for the longest time Romo would make 2-3 of those "what the hell was that" throws a game, usually with bad results if the DB held on.

The coaches have to manage him to help him mange the game. He's got a hell of an offense around him so he doesn't have to be Wonder Boy and he seemed to understand that in his interview. But that's talk and not under fire from a NFL defense. What helps control expectations is recalling what great QBs in college looked like their rookie seasons when they had to start. What elevates my expectations is those QBs didn't get to play in an offense this good. Everything is there for him to be successful.

And Dak may play well enough for us to win and be done in by this defense, don't trust them even a little bit at this point.
 
Top