FEATURED Sunday Games Thread

The Panthers can go ahead and start printing the NFC South division winner t-shirts. The Falcons are done without Penix. Panthers are getting stronger and already beat Atlanta in their building when they lucked out and played Cooper Rush :laugh:
 
Hamilton was right there….

You’d have to have Joe Milton throwing power to zip that in there
 
This might just be his worst year, but they have still neglected him since his time started there. Injuries have been massive, and you cannot replace the guys on his line who have literally not played any football the last few years. He does have to shoulder some blame as well
Im not blaming him. I know his organization is a trainwreck. I'm just wondering if he's a Top 25 QB anymore.
As mediocre as his skill positions and his offensive line are, how hard is it to have 0 games of a QB rating above 83.4? You can pull something out of your hat at least once.

Cam Ward has nothing to work with either, and he has at least one game above 90.0 rating.

Unless you know something about QB evaluations that I don't..... how would you evaluate this? I think Herbert struggles to make a Top 25 based on what we've seen this year.
 
Im not blaming him. I know his organization is a trainwreck. I'm just wondering if he's a Top 25 QB anymore.
As mediocre as his skill positions and his offensive line are, how hard is it to have 0 games of a QB rating above 83.4? You can pull something out of your hat at least once.

Cam Ward has nothing to work with either, and he has at least one game above 90.0 rating.

Unless you know something about QB evaluations that I don't..... how would you evaluate this? I think Herbert struggles to make a Top 25 based on what we've seen this year.
You can't really argue with how bad he has been this year, their entire team has been. Is he Top 25 in 2026 ? I don't see a world that he is, but he did rank in the Top 5
 

Staff online

Forum statistics

Threads
476,538
Messages
14,699,178
Members
24,234
Latest member
Justdatruth
Back
Top